Aspiring Lurker (He/Him)
I'll stand by it not being a large leap from "structure a campaign around dilemmas" to "make every choice be a dilemma." But yes, people pretty routinely react to something other than the words they're putatively reading.This is hardly the first time a thread has been started and the immediate interpretation of several people responding to it has been, "You want to do this in an unbelievably extreme and unrealistic way?! How unbelievable and unrealistic! I couldn't do that."
And that's if they're being nice.