I find Game Geeks entertaining, but I find Kurt a little too biased against d20 and bigger publishers to be a fair judge. He seems to be against any book that is a) available in print, b) has a page count greater than 100. The guy has come out and said that he hates 4e and doesn't particularly care for any edition of D&D.
I expect he'll declare as tie winners Spirit of the Century, Star Wars by WEG, and some PDF only Savage Worlds chapbook.
Retreater