D&D (2024) Half Race Appreciation Society: Half Elf most popular race choice in BG3

Do you think Half Elf being most popular BG3 race will cause PHB change?s?

  • Yes, Elf (and possibly other specieses) will get a hybrid option.

    Votes: 10 8.7%
  • Yes, a crunchier hybrid species system will be created

    Votes: 8 7.0%
  • Yes, a fluffier hybrid species system will be created

    Votes: 5 4.3%
  • No, the playtest hybrid rules will move forward

    Votes: 71 61.7%
  • No, hybrids will move to the DMG and setting books.

    Votes: 13 11.3%
  • Other

    Votes: 8 7.0%

So different, but still political reasons.
To avoid racism? It is less about politics and more about politeness and product appeal.

WotC wants African Americans to want to purchase and enjoy D&D.

Likewise, this inclusive friendly approach welcomes players from other countries to play D&D too.


Oppositely, to enforce racism feels weirdly "political" to me. We saw NuTSR. It enforced racism in a weirdly political way.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

@Scribe

I notice in the BG3 wiki, it says:

"BG3 Full Game Note: In the full launch of Baldur's Gate 3, Ability Score Points for Races that were present in Early Access are removed. And instead, Ability Score Points in the full game correspond with the Class players will choose."

Is it possible that the status of most-popular for the BG3 "Half-Elf" was only true when "races" assigned the ability score points, and now that the classes do instead, the Half-Elf is no longer as popular?
The stats about the popularity of the races/classes was complied from the post-release information.

I don't think the popularity of Half-Elf is some great mystery. They're both compelling aesthetically and mechanically in BG3. Aesthetics matter quite a bit in a visual medium like CRPGs, and the combination of darkvision, light armor, shield, and polearm proficiency, and the elven subrace choice is a lot of mechanical hooks for a variety of classes.
 


The stats about the popularity of the races/classes was complied from the post-release information.

I don't think the popularity of Half-Elf is some great mystery. They're both compelling aesthetically and mechanically in BG3. Aesthetics matter quite a bit in a visual medium like CRPGs, and the combination of darkvision, light armor, shield, and polearm proficiency, and the elven subrace choice is a lot of mechanical hooks for a variety of classes.
If I understand correctly, the BG3 stats released by Larian Studio represent the players during the weekend of the gaming release. So it is a kind of first impression. It seems informative about where the interest, curiosity, and energy is.
 

The stats about the popularity of the races/classes was complied from the post-release information.

I don't think the popularity of Half-Elf is some great mystery. They're both compelling aesthetically and mechanically in BG3. Aesthetics matter quite a bit in a visual medium like CRPGs, and the combination of darkvision, light armor, shield, and polearm proficiency, and the elven subrace choice is a lot of mechanical hooks for a variety of classes.

I took Half-Elf (Wood) for the additional movement, and which faces/styles I could take. The origin options in BG3 not very compelling outside of really looks, unless its the Gith, Dragonborn, or Duergar.

It amounts to a Cantrip it feels like, or visually just not appealing.

So, Half-Elf. Then again Halsin is a Wood Elf I believe, which is comical as he is absolutely huge and jacked.
 

Only if you consider the idea drow can be non-evil political.

There is a drow npc in the original module and he's classic dagnasty evil. They might have wanted to contrast that.
They might want to, but there is no narrative requirement for every story to have contrasting morality for every species. Doing so in this circumstance, as a retcon, is almost certainly political.
 

To avoid racism? It is less about politics and more about politeness and product appeal.

WotC wants African Americans to want to purchase and enjoy D&D.

Likewise, this inclusive friendly approach welcomes players from other countries to play D&D too.


Oppositely, to enforce racism feels weirdly "political" to me. We saw NuTSR. It enforced racism in a weirdly political way.
Again, does every story need every species to reflect the full spectrum of morality?
 


Again, does every story need every species to reflect the full spectrum of morality?


To be clear.

In this context, the part that is "racist" is the color-coding of the Elf. In old school D&D the "Good" Elf has light skin and the "Evil" Elf has dark skin. This is something that many African Americans noticed and were less than thrilled with.

Today the Elf species continues to be extremely popular among D&D fans. In Baldurs Gate 3, the various Elves (High, Drow, and Half) are together far more popular than Human. How WotC officially describes the Elf species matters for how people perceive D&D generally.


WotC resolves this problematic in two ways.

• Both the High Elf and the Drow Elf are now "Any Alignment".

• Both the High Elf and the Drow Elf can exhibit a range of skin complexions from light to dark.


The spectrum of skin complexions has always been true in the lore, even in old school D&D, even if it can be surprising when calling attention to this lore. The dark complexion High Elf has a bluish dark skin, and the light complexion Drow Elf has a very pale silvery complexion. In Tashas, there is an illustration of a High Elf and a Drow Elf. It took me a while to realize − and judging by the hair color − the light complexion Elf (with white hair) is Drow, and the dark complexion Elf (with black hair) is High.


Ever since Gygax himself invented the Drow, it is the cult of Lolth that cultivates an Evil Drow culture. There have always been Drow communities who dont adhere to the Lolth cult. For D&D 5e, it is fine to emphasize that the followers of Lolth are a "faction". By extension, most Drow dont belong to this faction and are "normal" Elves of "any alignment".

The "mark" of Lolth is now understood to be a decorative tattoo-like web pattern. Only high level Drow who are the most ardent supporters of Lolth receive this mark.


Where the Drow Half-Elf becomes a Drow full Elf in Pandelver, it seems like part of the wider effort to give examples of Drow who are "normal" and who arent members of the Lolth faction.
 
Last edited:


Remove ads

Top