ChatGPT had a couple of ideas that sounded interesting. Make the shield tattered and dented. I think it was to make him a true opposite to Cap. An actual Confederate soldier that thawed out in modern times. A revenant or zombie.
I wasn't clear but I was looking more for it to create an image. I was in a hurry trying to get it before leaving for work. Now that I'm home I can work on the concept more.
While I said they won the war, it was barely. After the South won Gettysburg Lincoln signed a treaty. The borders stayed the same. I want to show how the lack of diversity has held them back. No non-whites or women were allowed to get an education or position of authority. Only white men could vote. Foreigners, including people from the US, were discouraged from staying long term and never granted citizenship.
Large cities like Atlanta and Charlotte never developed like they did in our universe.
I don't know if I can find a real world analog to compare it to. If I did it would probably offend someone. lol North Korea minus the Communism? Communism-ish? Marx and Engel had some good ideas but they couldn't give up their Southern Baptist faith.
I want to make the current president a carpetbagger from New York. A failed real estate mogul and failed TV host. Whoever the tyrant is, Sean Hannity will be his chief propagandist. This will be one of the constants across universes. I can't stand the man. I will encourage any PC with super strength to do what Hulk did to Loki to Sean.