Bront
The man with the probe
I've talked about this with a few friends, but wanted to get some views here from the board.
It is my suposition that:
Dumbledore either is not dead, and simply arranged with Snape to fake it, or, at least arranged for his own death to inspire Harry.
Points:
1) Some of the death scene seem a bit too choriographed.
2) Snape is supposedly a master of casting spells without speaking, so could have easily cast a different spell instead of the killing spell and simply disguised it.
3) The actual death didn't take place in the school, as he was blown out of it.
4) Durring the chase, Snape seems to be lecturing Harry on casting without speaking instead of simply dealing with him with a stun or hold spell of some kind. It seemed like more of a lecture than a taunt.
5) Snape and Dumbledore seem to have a trusting relationship, at least it's hinted at, so the two working up this plan seems possable or even likely.
I'd like to hear any thoughts on this.
It is my suposition that:
Dumbledore either is not dead, and simply arranged with Snape to fake it, or, at least arranged for his own death to inspire Harry.
Points:
1) Some of the death scene seem a bit too choriographed.
2) Snape is supposedly a master of casting spells without speaking, so could have easily cast a different spell instead of the killing spell and simply disguised it.
3) The actual death didn't take place in the school, as he was blown out of it.
4) Durring the chase, Snape seems to be lecturing Harry on casting without speaking instead of simply dealing with him with a stun or hold spell of some kind. It seemed like more of a lecture than a taunt.
5) Snape and Dumbledore seem to have a trusting relationship, at least it's hinted at, so the two working up this plan seems possable or even likely.
I'd like to hear any thoughts on this.