I dunno. I guess that’s great and all that your players are willing to pretend they don’t know stuff is there, but I put it in the same category is pretending to not know about trolls and fire. I’d prefer that DMs give me monsters whose abilities I genuinely don’t know, just like I would prefer to genuinely not know what my character can’t see. I’d rather share the experience my character is having, than pretend to.I know it's unpopular opinion, but I just can't seem to grasp how hard it is for some people to use light & darkness. While I play on a VTT, I don't have the nifty Dynamic Lighting (which is a paid feature, and I'm cheap). All I do is give the general description to the group, and the players know if they can see it or not based on their character's vision. It's not any different than when a Darkness spell is cast. Maybe I've been spoiled by good players? Of course, despite having darkvision, most of our groups use light sources anyway, since the penalty for dim light can be problematic.
Criminally underrated spell in a dungeon adventure in my view.I had a group that insisted on relying on Darkvision. Around the third trap they missed due to their passive Perceptions being lowered by 5, somebody asked the Sorcerer to cast Dancing Lights.
Heh, drop a couple of baddies with the Skulker feat if you have parties that insist on relying on dark vision all the time.![]()
The problem is that outside of a VTT with dynamic lighting and separate voice channels, that's pretty much impossible. You always have information your character would not, simply by hearing what a DM says to the other players. Besides, this seldom actually matters, as I explain below.I dunno. I guess that’s great and all that your players are willing to pretend they don’t know stuff is there, but I put it in the same category is pretending to not know about trolls and fire. I’d prefer that DMs give me monsters whose abilities I genuinely don’t know, just like I would prefer to genuinely not know what my character can’t see. I’d rather share the experience my character is having, than pretend to.
The thing everyone forgets is darkvision gives you dim light which is disadvantage on perception checks and renders your vision black and white. It’s not as awesome as most people think it is. The problem is cantrips like light. Ban that cantrip and follow the actual rules on darkvision and you’re 70% of the way there.If so many races didn’t have Darkvision, and it wasn’t so burdensome to implement in game I might agree on the use of more darkness in the game. As it is, it’s just an annoyance to the point all my dungeons are essentially prelit these days.