MNblockhead
A Title Much Cooler Than Anything on the Old Site
Note, if using Chessex matts, you want WET erase markers. I've always bought Expo. Never had any issues with them. Just don't mix them with dry-erase markers or Sharpies.This is kind of what I was assuming. Stick to theater of the mind for the most part and then use the tiles when needed.
Do you have any recommendations for dry-erase markers? I got some cheap ones off Amazon and while the black ones are okay, all of the colored ones that came in the pack are barely visible.

Note even for dungeon tiles and plastic surfaces and matts that support dry erase, I MUCH prefer wet erase. They don't smudge as easily. You do need a damp cloth or wipe to erase, but when moving minis around, etc. the wet erase marks and drawing hold up much better than dry erase. I've even had laminated character sheets for some games that I used wet erase with.