• Welcome to this new upgrade of the site. We are now on a totally different software platform. Many things will be different, and bugs are expected. Certain areas (like downloads and reviews) will take longer to import. As always, please use the Meta Forum for site queries or bug reports. Note that we (the mods and admins) are also learning the new software.
  • The RSS feed for the news page has changed. Use this link. The old one displays the forums, not the news.

How often does your party use a potion of healing

how often does you party use potion for healing

  • Never! we don't use magic

    Votes: 1 2.6%
  • once per long rest

    Votes: 20 52.6%
  • once per short rest

    Votes: 7 18.4%
  • once per encounter

    Votes: 4 10.5%
  • two or more potions per encounter

    Votes: 6 15.8%

  • Total voters
    38

DM Dave1

Exploder
On average, I'd say less than once per long rest in our games. But I've also seen multiple times per encounter when the primary healer of the party got knocked out!
 

iserith

Explorer
It doesn't come up a whole lot in our games. Typically a potion is used to get a PC back up on his or her feet after they've gone down. Sometimes if there is no healing PC at the session and they don't have time to rest they might top themselves off with some potions.
 
Only in emergencies. I’m not sure we’ve ever bought one in 50+ sessions of our current campaign. That’s money we don’t want to spend. That leaves the ones we occasionally find along the way. We tend to save the few of those we come across until we know we are in or going to be in a dangerous spot and need more healing right then than we can get with spells. So if you are talking about long rests in an “Adventuring Day”, perhaps we’re in the ballpark of one per 15 to 20 long rests.

By the poll options I think your expectations aren’t aligned with the way the game is assumed to be played. Sure, if you have the cash and nothing else to spend it on, you could make potions a part of your daily health regime like rations and water, but that isn’t how I’ve ever seen the game played. If you’re coming from 4e (or a lot of computer games) that’s one of many things that is completely different.
 
Last edited:

Sacrosanct

Slayer of Keraptis
I'm afraid none of the poll options work. We use them, but there's no way to break it down by encounter. A PC might have one or two potions, but we don't use them unless we need to. So we can go days without, or we could use them all during the actual encounter. It all depends.
 

Odysseus

Explorer
anybody got any suggestions about how to measure how many parties are using.
The replies so far seem to be little to none ,but sometimes a lot.
 

ad_hoc

Explorer
We use as many as we need to get back to full health for the next encounter. So that's 0 if we're taking a short rest, but multiple if not.

Gold isn't useful to have if we're all dead.
 
We probably average one potion per long rest. Those really tend to come out when a character is downed and making death saves. Sort of like a magical AED defibrillator.

Adventurers League play tends to be different. Generally, long rests, and sometimes even short rests, aren’t a guaranteed thing. Neither is having a cleric with healing spells. Without dedicated healing or the ability to refresh those spell slots, I know I’ve had plenty of characters chug potion after potion in-between encounters.
 

LordEntrails

Explorer
I put one per short rest, but that's not very accurate.

My players are in Undermountain (old school, not DoMM) so they don't often find healing potions.
When they use healing potions, they tend to use several because its a big fight and they are in trouble etc. But, they only use healing potions maybe once every 10 fights, but then they tend to use all the ones they have.

As GM, you have control over how many healing potions they have access to. Yes, they are i the PHB, but if its a problem with them using too many, then you can simple say they are not available. It's very reasonable that the herbalist in town might only make 1 per week, and the party is not the only one buying them.
 

jgsugden

Explorer
Uhhh... that poll is missing a lot of options.

In standard games, potions are rarely used, and are pimarily used to bring a downed ally back up, or between battles where there is insufficient time for a short rest.

In many games I play, the use of a potion is a bonus action. In those games, potions are used more often - potentially 1 or 2 potions per LR.
 

Blue

Orcus on a bad day
Several times during really tough encounters, but usually zero during the vast majority of encounters.

The poll needs more irregular options.
 

Shiroiken

Explorer
Our group likes to have them on hand, primarily to get someone back up (especially the healer) in combat. Outside of combat they're used if we have to push on without a rest and don't have any healing left other than potions. DMs in our games also heavily restrict how many we can buy in any given locations to keep us from just stocking up.
 

ccs

39th lv DM
In the 5e game I'm playing in?
We guzzle healing potions like ail....Course that could be that before last session we didn't have a cleric, or really anyone with Cure Wounds. What we do have is GP. And some players use more potions than others.

In the 5e game I run? It's rare that the players use consumable magics.
 

BookBarbarian

Expert Long Rester
2 times out of however many sessions is "weekly sessions since August". I'd rather have it when I need it when use it instead of a spell slot that will recharge, or a hit dice that will recharge.
 
I

Immortal Sun

Guest
I just don't hand them out or sell them except in very rare occasions. It's one of those setting implications I just don't like.
 

Oofta

Explorer
It depends on the group and how many fights you have between rests. For example, do you have a cleric, druid or bard? Does anyone have the healer feat? A healers kit is cheaper than potions and heal more, although it is limited to once per short rest.

I wouldn't worry about it too much. I generally make a handful available at lower level and then let them purchase them as they are common items.
 

Legatus_Legionis

< BLAH HA Ha ha >
My RPG games are usually full of magic and treasures and hard combats.

It is rich in both magical item shops and for those hard to get items - for a price.

So if the group does not have a healer they have plenty of options.
 

Advertisement

Top