The absolute highlight, though, was Meepo, the NPC kobold. Not only did Meepo hit with almost every shot of his sling, with good damage rolls, he also crit multiple times. At the very end of the fight, the last surviving baddie tried to flee and risked an opportunity attack from Meepo. Bad idea. Another crit, baddie dead, fight over.
After roleplaying Meepo as timid and bashful the whole adventure, every time he killed another bad guy or got another critical, the DM had him saying, "I AM INVINCIBLE!!!!" or some such in roll20 chat.
I ended up with
Shatterspike, but really it should have gone to Meepo.