D&D 5E I’d be glad for MAD

[Undrave]

Because then you are forcing my wisdom fighter to fight differently than a charisma one when the probably isn’t actually going to be the case.

I mean instead of in-battle abilities that key off CHA or WIS they would just have out of combat stuff that exploits those stats. Because Fighters could always use actual out of combat abilities.

don’t want to face the choice of choosing an ability score I don’t like as much because it makes for a better fighter - which is what almost always happens.

Or to have to decide between using the mechanical abilities I like better (but are perfectly balanced) at the expense of fighter conception I really wanted due to the stats not aligning.

For me your proposal removes important choices from me.

What’s the point of picking a stat over another if it doesn’t change anything?

What’s the point of a choice if you don’t sacrifice anything when making that choice?

I don't really get what you want it to look like? What does it mean to build a STR/CHA Fighter vs STR/WIS fighter?