stuart
First Post
I see this a lot and it constantly confuses me.
Older editions of D&D were clearly written with miniatures in mind. That's why movement and spell areas in AD&D is listed in inches for example, so you could measure it off like they did with wargames not played on a grid.
People who started from a wargaming background or were introduced to the game by those players probably used minis more often. People who started in the 80s from a Choose Your Own Adventure / Lord of the Rings background with the Basic D&D rules probably didn't use minis as often. I say this because right on the cover of the Mentzer edition "Red Box" basic D&D rules it says "This game requires no gameboard because the action takes place in the player's imagination". It definitely gave me the idea that minis were very optional and the default way of playing the game was with it all "in the player's imagination".
I know that's not how everyone played it... but I know I'm not alone in getting that impression from the Red Box rules either.