Job Titles for a Medieval Official?

Status
Not open for further replies.
What? :confused:

A harbour is precisely a refuge.

Ok. Is a refuge precisely a harbor?

Yes, a harbor is a refuge but it is not 'precisely' a refuge. A harbor, in the modern sense, is a member of the super-class refuge - a particular instance of the general class. A harbor in the medevial sense was a synonym of refuge - the general class itself. We might still figuratively use harbor occasionally to mean refuge, but we'd never talk about today, finding a harbor for our horses, or finding a harbor to stay for the night, or about the army finding a habor to make camp unless we were talking about also a place to put boats. We know longer use harbor regularly to mean 'refuge'. Conversely, until the early modern, 'habor' was not primarily used to mean 'a protected refuge for boats'.

Also, it's worth noting that you don't have to 'build' a harbor. You are thinking of harbor in the sense of something constructed, but that's recent and shows that harbor is actually replacing 'quay', 'port', and 'jetty' and things like that in modern usage. Not that long ago, anyone using the term harbor would have pretty much certainly been thinking of natural features of the land, not something that was 'built'.

Language changes.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

I want to give this guy a title that will sound archaic and appropriate to my players. Absolute historical accuracy is less important to me than flavor.

I'm going with Portshrieve or Bondmaster. I'm not at all interested in the pissing contest over the OED.

Can the mods close this thread please?
 


Status
Not open for further replies.
Remove ads

Top