Obryn
Hero
For some people, it's probably true, right?
God forbid I use a videogame analogy -- the only videogame I play is Rock Band -- but I know players and designers of fighting games who think that the ultimate goal is to make all of the characters balanced. As I said, I don't play, but as a novice playing another novice, I'd be pretty annoyed if I had no chance with Sonya against Scorpion. (Yes, that game, the original, is the last fighting game I played. On Sega Genesis.)
RPGs are obviously different, but for at least some people -- lots of whom are 4E fans -- balance is pretty important to their fun. And I can understand it. I want balance, too ... I just enforce it (as DM) or trust my DM to enforce it (as a player).
As an aside, for all the "verisimilitude" haters, if you can give me another word in the English language that has the same precision of meaning, I'll be glad to use it instead. If you can't, calling for it to be "un-worded" is --------ing ---hat-ish in the ---her----ing extreme.
(Are you trying to fill in the blanks? Are you? Be honest!)
You forgot theAnd yet none of those words actually means the same thing as "verisimilitude." Surely you haven't missed all the threads in which some poor sap used "realism" when he meant "verisimilitude" and got 20 sneering replies explaining to him that "fireballs and elves aren't realistic, you stupid bastard." Have you?
"Verisimilitude" is an extraordinarily precise word. I have the vocabulary of God, and I don't know of another word with the same meaning. Sure, you can get the meaning across with phrases -- "internally consistent realism," for instance -- but not with one word.
I'd be in favor of shortening it, though, because that's just how lazy I roll. "Dude, healing surges offend v-tude!"

Twice.
EPIC FAIL!
-O