rycanada said:
Dungeons & Zombies is great, but I was really looking to find a balance between D&D and Buffy (rather than D&D and All Flesh Must Be Eaten). D&Z helped me find that balance - but if you look at the final result it seems like I've completely ignored D&Z.
Sounds cool! Angel/Buffy is one of my favourite systems. (My other favs: RC D&D, and Castles and Crusades. Obviously, as a GM, I am a pretty 'rules light' person.) D&Z is great, but I too prefer the 'Cinematic' version of Unisystem.
Anyway, to recap, my recommendations are: UK2-4, B10, Lost City of Barrakus, and the Goodman stuff.
The OAD&D modules N1 (Cult of the Reptile God), L1 (Secret of Bone Hill), and L2 (Assassin's Knot) are all very good for starting groups as well.
I think most of the OD&D and O AD&D stuff might be available as pdfs at RPG.now. L1 is available for free over at WotC.
Hmmm ... now that I am thinking about this. Some campaign material I have found really amazing and inspirational (but probably hard to find now) include: The Court of Ardor (an old ICE/MERP campaign module by Terry Amthor -- it includes one of the coolest 'evil' organizations in any fantasy module) and Jaiman (an old ICE/Shadow World setting with adventures, also by Terry Amthor). In fact, since you don't care about the system, I would recommend most of the old ICE Middle-earth products. They include nice overviews of cities, adventures, etc., but don't overload you with information. Moreover, IMO, most of them could be easily adapted to a non-Middle-earth setting (and indeed, many of them like Ardor were a poor fit for Middle-earth in the first place).
I could probably help more if I knew what kind of campaign you were planning on running.