Magic: Innate or Learned?

Tinker Gnome

Adventurer
Is Magic in your games Innate or learned? Can anyone learn it if they put enough effort into it? Or is it impossible if a person is not born with the "Spark"?

IMC, magic can be learned by anyone. Some people may have a harder time of it than others, but anyone who is willing to put enogh effort into it can learn it.

The same goes for Psionics.
 

log in or register to remove this ad



Neither, both, and yes & no. Part of the way I try to keep magic being "magical" is never defining it. One wizard may explain his powers from years of study, while another is from a long line of them.

If I define it, I take away some of the mystical properties, imo. Not that I dislike the defiinitions in other games or campaign settings, it's just been my preference that magic is because it is and that's it.
 



Anyone can learn magic, but some people have such an innate, instinctive knack for it that they require little or no formal training.
 

It changes from campaign to campaign. Though most often I don't specify. There is no point to specifying the true nature of magic unless it is going to be relevant to the plot in some way. People in the game world can believe either or both. Whether what they believe is the truth is a separate question.
 

A wizard's magic is learned.
The sorcerer's is innate but anyone with enough charisma has the potential (no bloodline or Harry Potter bs)
 

It depends.

In a magical world I expect people to have evolved to have a biology that is capable of interacting to some degree with magic. Most have a limited ability and can never get beyond the basics - thus part of the reason for many of the lowest level magic using NPCs. They literally cannot get further along even if they were to train for decades, adventure, etc.

Some have greater ability. While it might be called a 'spark' it is more accurately referred to as either heritage (1, 5, 10, 50, etc generations back, one of your ancestors was a fey, fiend, celestial, etc) or the blessing of a powerful entity (deity, fey, fiend, etc).

In the former case the caster has an innate ability which might have revealed itself through minor incidences of wild magic, odd luck, etc that some trainer in the arts recognized, leading to the start of training. Or perhaps the nacient mage was studying old tomes and found that some of the spells / etc in them worked for him despite not working for others.

In the latter case, a dream or a series of strange coincidences might have lead to a potential cleric, druid, etc stumbling upon a high master of the arts and thus becoming a student. They may not have been born with the ability (at least not to any great degree), but their minor innate ability was expanded greatly by some entity with an interest either in the individual or what the individual might do for them in the future - if suitably empowered and trained.
 

Pets & Sidekicks

Remove ads

Top