MIC trumps DMG?

[Stalker0]

The DMG trumps all others by default...however, the dm of course decides what material to use. In general I allow the MIC to trump the dmg.

 

[amethal]

Ladies and gents, let's not get a flame war going, please.

I only resurrected this thread so I could eat humble pie for Mistwell

I suppose if it gets locked he'll have to find somewhere else to gloat

 

[amethal]

I only resurrected this thread so I could eat humble pie for Mistwell

With grateful thanks to Eric Anondson, I give you "Potion of enlarge person".

http://www.enworld.org/showthread.php?t=197294

250 gp per the DMG page 230 and the hypertext SRD.

50 gp per the MIC page 256.

 

[Perun]

With grateful thanks to Eric Anondson, I give you "Potion of enlarge person".

http://www.enworld.org/showthread.php?t=197294

250 gp per the DMG page 230 and the hypertext SRD.

50 gp per the MIC page 256.

That's probably because they referenced the DMG 3.0 potion table, which listed a potion of enlarge at 5th-level, which was also 250 gp.

The potion of enlarge person (as well as the potion of reduce person, listed right below it in both tables) should probably be made at 5th caster level, which sets the price at 250 gp (spell level [1] multiplied by caster level [5] multiplied by 50 gp = 250 gp).

The MIC simply turns it back into a 1st-level item.

Regards.