Mithral and Armor Proficiency...

[trentonjoe]

Isearched but couldn't find it.

Must have been on the old boards.

Or the real old boards.

Or I am making this all up!

 

[Crothian]

Isearched but couldn't find it.

Must have been on the old boards.

Or the real old boards.

Or I am making this all up!

No, I remember it it. It was just rediculus. The idea that you could weld a mithral bastard sword as a light weapon for a medium sized person was very laughible.

 

[Wolf72]

No, I remember it it. It was just rediculus. The idea that you could weld a mithral bastard sword as a light weapon for a medium sized person was very laughible.

most definitely on the old boards! and yes crothian has the verdict correct!

*don't listen to much to wolf tonight, he's still suffereing from hunger ... hmm, maybe time to grab a bite to eat?*

 

[Crothian]

most definitely on the old boards! and yes crothian has the verdict correct!

*don't listen to much to wolf tonight, he's still suffereing from hunger ... hmm, maybe time to grab a bite to eat?*

Just get yourself some Ramon Noodles and you'll be fine.

 

[Ysgarran]

Ok, it's pretty clear that the latest rulings support the fact that MW and Mithral stack.
<snip>

I don't believe that they stack, I'm guessing with the next release of the FAQ the mithral statement will be modified.

DMG, pg 243, second paragraph.

Weapons or armors fashioned from mithral are treated as masterwork items with regard to creation times, but the masterwork quality does not affect the enhancement bonus of the weapons or the armor check penalty of the armor.

 

[Crothian]

But is that saying that all items made from Mithral are considered MW (with out the bonuses) so they can be enchanted.

Or does it mean that making anything is the same DC as a MW version (thus not getting any of the MW bonuses) but it can't be made magical becasue it's not technically MW?

 

[Wolf72]

But is that saying that all items made from Mithral are considered MW (with out the bonuses) so they can be enchanted.

Or does it mean that making anything is the same DC as a MW version (thus not getting any of the MW bonuses) but it can't be made magical becasue it's not technically MW?

aaaaaaahhhhhhhhh!!!!! stop the nightmare!!!!

oh, and ramen noodles on the way! (as soon as the water boils ... check that, I'm gonna nuke em ... no boil, nuke, boil ... I might be a while!)

 

[Ysgarran]

But is that saying that all items made from Mithral are considered MW (with out the bonuses) so they can be enchanted.

Or does it mean that making anything is the same DC as a MW version (thus not getting any of the MW bonuses) but it can't be made magical becasue it's not technically MW?

Um, do ramen noodles go bad? I think I must have box of the stuff around here somewhere...

Ysgarran.

 

[Crothian]

Um, do ramen noodles go bad? I think I must have box of the stuff around here somewhere...

Ysgarran.

I think they have a self life slightly lower then a twinky

 

[kreynolds]

oh god, ~SKR has gotten into the chocolate again!

Huh?