The single most common criticism I've seen of BoXM has to do with fighters, by which, I assume people really mean non-spellcasters. They range from "there's nothing new for fighters," which is mostly true, although a lot of the optional rules are as useful to them as anyone, to "the book hoses fighters," which I'd argue with other than the point I made right in the book (a feat per level decreases the value of bonus fighter feats slightly).
However, in thinking about all this, I have come up with a whole bunch of BoXM-style ideas for non-spellcasters (and for fighters especially).
I'm wondering if this is of interest. Which is to say, of interest enough for me to compile them into a small BoXM style book, for Sue to edit it, etc. It would be shorter than BoXM and thus cheaper. We could make it a lulu book as well.
