More Greyhawk questions

[grodog]

Anything in particular?

Definitely, Olive: the materials in the Greyhawk Apocrypha topic at http://www.canonfire.com/htmlnew/modules.php?name=News&new_topic=47 are where you'll find this type of information.

 

[Olive]

Definitely, Olive: the materials in the Greyhawk Apocrypha topic at http://www.canonfire.com/htmlnew/modules.php?name=News&new_topic=47 are where you'll find this type of information.

Thanks.

 

[grodog]

De nada!

 

[diaglo]

I tried to argue for a more critical look at what to regard is 'canon'. My arguemnt is if you include everything published by TSR/WotC in all editions you get a entagled mess of conflicting ideas, and plus some stuff that's not very good quality.

i agree with you johnsemlak.

anything after Supplement I Greyhawk, i view as suspect.

and definitely anything after 1985 is garbage/rubbish.

but you can't post a thread anywhere on the net concerning Greyhawk and get 2 people to completely agree...unless one is a sock puppet.

 

[grodog]

anything after Supplement I Greyhawk, i view as suspect.

Now diaglo, you know that there was almost nothing about Greyhawk in the Greyhawk supplement (and using the tricks/traps and Enigma of GH illustration as the basis is pushing it...).

but you can't post a thread anywhere on the net concerning Greyhawk and get 2 people to completely agree...unless one is a sock puppet.

LOL! Too true....