Hi again!
Posted by arwink:
Also the reason some of us loved the Wrath of the Immortals. What can I say? I play fighters 
Besides, if you're going to mess with a campaign world like that, you may as well make it really, really interesting...
Well, Thyatis got a pretty good pasting too, but yes, I'm sure the fighter-types weren't shedding too many tears over the colossal damage done to the two haughty magocracies of the Known World...
And potential for at least a couple of the really major events was hinted at in some of the Expert- and Companion-level modules for BD&D, but I admit I never thought they'd have the guts to actually put them in a published product and make them part of the official current continuity. Shows what I knew.
Posted by Dahak:
I have a complete (as I would measure it) set: 14 Gazetteers and Dawn, 4 Creature Crucibles, the Hollow World set and supplements, the Trail Maps, Champions of Mystara and Wrath.
You're obviously blessed with foresight. A friend and I had pretty much everything between us, but we live very far apart now, and so both have big gaps in our individual collections. And the
Poor Wizard's Almanac series is worth looking into; they're handy little references for when you don't want to dig through a big stack of books for some world data, and they're also about the best source of info I have on Wendar, since I'm still waiting on GAZ 15 (especially with what was done to Alfheim post-Wrath!).
Posted by Dahak:
Collectively it is in my opinion the best setting ever released for D&D. I would love to see a 3E version that captured the setting's somewhat over-the-top nature, without resorting to kid-ifying it like some of the AD&D line did.
If I had to pick just one AD&D setting to get the lavish 3e Realms-style treatment, it would probably be Mystara (though passing over Birthright would be a real heartbreaker). I know what you mean about the "kidifying", though - it started to show up even under the BD&D rules, when they ditched the term "witch doctor" for "wokani". Still, it didn't seem quite so bad in Mystara, which was pretty youth-oriented to begin with.
Posted by JohnNephew:
Thanks for the kind words about PC1. It's really nice to read them.
Ach! A published author of Mystaran materials posts here, and I don't recognize him until someone else points him out. I've been too long without a good read through my materials...
Here are a few more good words, though. I was very impressed by the Creature Crucible series in general, and I thought
Tall Tales of the Wee Folk did an excellent job of setting up and maintaining the whole "fantasy-Celtic" atmosphere. Though I'm echoing Dahak here, I'll say that your treatment of the Fair Folk as dwindled quasi-deities displays a wonderful feel for both the Celtic source legends and the BD&D/Mystara cosmology. And ya gotta love rules for playable PC treants, hsiao, and POOKA!
Your Dreamland court unfortunately got rather short shrift post-Wrath. If I remember correctly, their only mention was in a "Known World Grimoire" column in Dragon, where it was basically said that they were withdrawn into a pocket dimension, and wouldn't be coming back anytime soon. Serraine popped up from time to time in the
Poor Wizard's Almanacs, and the crew from
Night Howlers got Morlay-Malinbois, but I don't remember seeing anything about the vast territories of the Sea People. Might make for some interesting adventures...
Posted by JohnNephew:
Let me just say that I would personally find it a real joy to bring Mystara (heh, I still think of it as "Known World") books out for D20.
May it one day be so. I'd settle for just one really, really good one (again, using the 3e Realms hardcover as my standard of excellence), though that Wendar Gazetteer would be nice as well...
The Vaults of Pandius is a valuable resource with some excellent articles (my favorite is the one on Ochalean Immortals), and it has helped keep the flames of Mystara fandom alive, but it's no substitute for books in hand, and much of the new material there (like the NACE and other timeline additions) seems uninspired.
Ah well, one can dream...
