I voted for both. Narnia is someting new and the grapichs are awsome. While Kong is a remake, it is both very similar (if you didn't like the original you probably wont like this version) while at the same time being very diffrent. Not just in the special affects. This version pays more attention to why they are going to the island in the first place. Then much more adventures on the island. While having much less to do with what happens in New York. Personaly I do not feel there is any real comparison between the two. Both are awsome, just very diffrent stories.