New Releases: Complete Guide to Fey and Dungeon Crawl Classics #1: Idylls 3.5 Edition

RSKennan

Explorer
Hey Banshee, thanks for picking up the book. I’m hurtling towards a deadline, so I might give short answers but I’ll definitely try to make sure I get all of your questions.


Banshee16 said:
Well, I was going to ask how it treats Fey...as the Fey of D&D, as the potentially dark Faerie of more adult type myths, or more like Fairy Tales? Does it allow the creation of PCs, or just monsters? What's the flavour text like? Any new types of Fey? etc.

But, I was in the area of my local FLGS, picking up my gf, and went in and saw the book, and ended up picking it up.

So, now I have more specific questions of the designers :)

1-The Empyrean class....you show spells/day, and mention that they are spontaneous casters....but how many spells do they get to know? Can they learn any of the spells from their spell-list or are they limited like a sorcerer?

2-What spell list does an Empyrean use? The Fey Spells Master list? Or the Fey Spells by host lists?

They use the Fey spells master list and can choose freely as needed. They are not limited to a list beyond that. The Fey classes and feats are more powerful than their standard counterparts.


3-Can a Feyshaped creature begin changing more and more into a fey eldritch vestiture, magic weave etc.?

Yes. While the text says they are “not fully converted to being fey”, they are creatures of the Fey type. The difference between a fey who was ‘born’ that way, and one that was made that way is perceptual among some but not all fey.

4-Are the Fey races balanced against regular PC races, or should they be given EL's? What about the classes?

The races themselves are designed to be EL 0. A flat EL won’t balance a fey race with fey classes and feats though; adding them in makes things more powerful. My intention was that in a given campaign either the GM would use the book for NPC fey, or everyone would use the book for their characters- it’s not designed to easily mix with the standard game. Using standard classes with the fey feats and races could work for its own campaign though.

I could see having a special situation where the races but not the classes were available to PCs; maybe fey lost touch with their heritage on your world.

5-Could the Mysterial class be taken by regular PC's?

I wouldn’t allow it in a game where everyone else was playing standard races and classes, unless everyone had the option, and even then, I’d rather give a level-based bonus to everyone, say at every 5th level, like a ‘meta’feat, or something. That in itself would bring up a host of issues, but I’m not sure they’d be too big.

6-In the book, it discusses the fact that the Fey basically die when slain....unless a Remember to which they are tied changes the rules for that world or group of Fey. Many other books, such as Van Richten's Guide to Fey, posit that when Fey are slain, they actually reform in some new few shape.....not always remembering what they used to be. Could a Rememberer for a particular world set things that way?

Yes. A Rememberer is the ultimate hand wave for your fey campaign :) they can set the rules of fey life and death as much as they want.

7-How abstract can a Cynosure be? It seems like they're fairly restrictive....not all fey seem bound to a particular woodland etc......like pixies, grigs, etc. who can travel. This also comes into play when considering Fey PCs....a Cynosure could mean they couldn't travel with other party members.

Cynosure is the penultimate Handwave for your fey campaign :D It can be any one thing; from an ideal such as love, to a fey host, to the entire ocean, to a continent… the only caveat is that the fey must guard and protect its entire cynosure or deal with cruxes. I imagine that one of the more useful Cynosures would be a powerful Rememberer… a god or goddess that could take care of itself so the PCs could do whatever they needed to. Host as a cynosure would be a good choice too.

Imagine having a continent as a cynosure- even with the Deep Cynosure feat… it would only really be a problem when flying and sea travel became an issue. Of course if something happened to injure or threaten the continent- like a canal being built from one sea to the other- the character would have to do something of suffer a crux.

8-Do all Fey belong to a Host, and gain access to that Host's abilities?

Members of the Twilight court are hostless, since the Twilight court is its own host and grants no abilities. Fey-shaped creatures don’t need to join a host, and you could always rules that the Rememberer changed or did away with the hosts as they are laid out in the book. Other than what I said above, yes, any fey of the Nightmare or Dream courts belong to a host, and get the host abilities by level.

9-Have you considered using banes, such as those in Van Richten's Guide to the Fey, and Faeries by Bastion Press to offset abilities granted by some of those fey feats? Like inability to enter churches, being forced to step around particular objects, etc.?

I did consider that kind of thing, and they are present to some degree in the host vulnerabilities. I just figured that things were pretty complicated to begin with, so I tried to keep much of it to a minimum. A lot of these scenarios arise naturally from the rules- the Fey vulnerability to divine magic would keep a lot of them away from churches.

10-Are fey always bound to the five laws, no matter what their host or race is?

Yes. Some of the hosts have different ways of bending them though.

11-Can a fey change race? ie. could a puck evolve into a shee?

No; unless they came back from death that way. You could work up an alternate Reincarnation creature list, assuming you like the idea of them changing every time they come back. You could rule that the Rememberer allows any resurrection/life-giving magic to work, but that they work as a reincarnate spell with the list you use.

The book seems very interesting. I'm still sort of digesting things, but I'm thinking along the lines of combining aspects from this book with both Faeries (Bastion Press) and Van Richten's guide to Fey.

Hopefully these questions made sense. I find it a pretty cool book, and Fey are one topic that hasn't been dealt with very much by the D20 industry....and there is a lot of ground to cover with them. I really like how this book is flexible enough to have several different takes on how they work.

Banshee

Thanks for all the questions. I hope I answered them all well enough. Let me know if you have other questions. Enjoy the book!
 
Last edited:

log in or register to remove this ad

Banshee16

First Post
Your answers do help...thanks a lot. I'm going to have to copy all this to a reference document of some sort.

One of the characters in my campaign was slain, and reincarnated as a dryad. Originally I used the rules from "Faeries" by Bastion Press to create her, but may try this as an alternative, or blend the two systems. Right now, the player is playing her along the lines of her old body....but maybe she will start to find herself bound increasingly by the rules etc. I'll talk to the player about it first, to gauge his opinion.

Banshee
 

Remove ads

Top