EvilMountainDew
First Post
Heh, now i have to think of what itll say...
OOC: Elvish Misconceptions
- Thread starter EvilMountainDew
- Start date
Thomas Hobbes
First Post
By-the-by, what pantheon are we using here? In the IC thread I just had my character invoke Obad-Hai (also known as "shawm"), but I'm not sure that's correct- this should be relevant to Argent's Paladin, too.
other notes, since you wanted some tips on DMing style.
Argent shoudn't have killed that guard, just knocked him out- even with Smite, he was dealing only subdual damage. Also, and although this was in my favor, you should proboably given the dumb guard a save- even if "the worked earth is smarter", there's still something like a 10% chance I'll have a very un-charmed man on my hands... if a PCs save was really low, he'd certainly want a chance, even a slim one.
Hope that's the sort of thing you were looking for.
other notes, since you wanted some tips on DMing style.
Argent shoudn't have killed that guard, just knocked him out- even with Smite, he was dealing only subdual damage. Also, and although this was in my favor, you should proboably given the dumb guard a save- even if "the worked earth is smarter", there's still something like a 10% chance I'll have a very un-charmed man on my hands... if a PCs save was really low, he'd certainly want a chance, even a slim one.Hope that's the sort of thing you were looking for.
Argent Silvermage
First Post
Thomas Hobbes said:By-the-by, what pantheon are we using here? In the IC thread I just had my character invoke Obad-Hai (also known as "shawm"), but I'm not sure that's correct- this should be relevant to Argent's Paladin, too.
other notes, since you wanted some tips on DMing style.
Hope that's the sort of thing you were looking for.
Perhaps the tips on DMing style should be privetly given. There is no need to chastize the DM in open forum. This is his 1st time DMing a PBP. set him right about the mistakes but not "in front" of the other players.
EvilMountainDew
First Post
OOC
Alright, I understand and I dont mind such a thing in this board... but I did what I thought was right and I knew it was subdual. NOTE, (1) I made this race up (2) I rolled 2 d20 hit points and he only had 5 (3) The strength and d3 of hitpoints killed him anyway (4) He was already in a fight with another!
Alright, I understand and I dont mind such a thing in this board... but I did what I thought was right and I knew it was subdual. NOTE, (1) I made this race up (2) I rolled 2 d20 hit points and he only had 5 (3) The strength and d3 of hitpoints killed him anyway (4) He was already in a fight with another!
Thomas Hobbes
First Post
I'm glad you didn't take offense, EMD; none was meant to be given. And the point is conceeded.
And the point is conceeded.
GnomeWorks
Adventurer
EMD - I suggest that you go to the Table of Contents thread and post your game information there, so that it will be easier to find the OoC threads if they fall off the first page (which will happen eventually).
You may also want to start a thread over in the Rogues Gallery to keep track of the characters.
You may also want to start a thread over in the Rogues Gallery to keep track of the characters.
EvilMountainDew
First Post
Fair 'nuff
