Mustrum_Ridcully
Legend
To be fair, since the 4E PDFs were leaked two weeks before the release, 4E players had the same choice if they downloaded the books early.
Not exactly - the pirated copy is still illegal. Pathfinder Beta PDF is not.

Well, the difference might be that the Beta is marked as such. I don't agree with the notion that 4E is "incomplete" (but I agree there is still a lot left to explore - the Dragon content and the previews for the next books prove that - but I see that only as a good thing - I am not sure I "needed" all those "Completes" I bought...I never understood the excitement about buying the print version of Pathfinder Beta. After all the 4e detractors whine and scream about it not being a complete edition or not being playtested enough they then go line up for an incomplete game and the chance to pay to be a playtester. Does not compute.

Of course, another reason is because the Beta is intented for playtesting and to influence what the final will look like. It's your buy-in to be a contributor to a D&D game system. I bet some people would also given money if they could have been 4E playtesters...
The only time I might say that people are acting really irrational or inconsistent if they buy the Pathfinder Beta but complain that Starwars Saga and the Book of Nine Swords where "playtest" versions and they are somehow offended or disappointed by it. But I am not sure that such a
