It's amusing what my spell checker wanted to replace Prestidigitation with...
I wrote:
> > (There's nothing in the Suggestion spell description that says it
> > can't work on a sleeping person, so that they won't CONSCIOUSLY
> > remember the suggestion. Suggestion : "Master Duelist Lord
> > Other-Blackmailer has been insulting your honor. You must publicly
> > challenge him to defend your honor." Especially effective if you've
> > previously been using Alter Self to spread rumors.)
Turanil replied:
> Excellent!! I love that!
Thank you.
> A player who would do that in my campaign would automatically succeed
> the intended result (with maybe some unexpected side effect), and
> would get an important XP bonus!
Perhaps the winner of the duel is injured and laid up for a
few days? Vrecknidj only mentioned arcane spellcasting as
being outlawed, so I assume the winner of the duel could
'make a donation to the church'.
The Suggestion spell has guidelines for modifiers for
'reasonable' suggestions. With prior disguised
rumor-mongering, I'd allow the above to automatically
influence the victim's belief, but if they made their save
even at a -2 circumstance penalty, I might say they decided
their life is more important than their honor. Regardless,
with prior legwork, I'd allow such a suggestion to cause
problems for the victim whether or not the save was made.
I wouldn't CONSISTENTLY allow such problems even with a made
save, though, because then why wouldn't everybody do it?
As far as XP? If an NPC were blackmailing a PC, I'd give
that PC XP for defeating the NPC even for indirect stuff
like setting up a duel they couldn't win -- especially if
the PC made arrangements to prevent the NPC's blackmail
evidence (if any) from falling into the hands of others.
(BTW: When using Alter Self for disguise, ALWAYS back it up
with a non-magical disguise underneath. So what if you
don't have the skill? You just don't want to be identified.
If the spell fails, you don't necessarily care about framing
someone else. Underneath an Alter Self spell, I like to
have a Hollywood-ninja-style bodysuit, and under that a
workman's outfit appropriate for the area. Cut your hair
short, different from your usual look. Alter Self
dispelled? Smoke grenade, run away, run to the supply
closet, yank the door open, tear off and hide the ninja
outfit, grab a mop bucket, spill it a little and fall down
before the pursuit rounds the corner. Point with fear on
your face and an open mouth. If anyone questions you,
stammer too much to say anything useful. Don't overdo the
eye-rolling. Later on, use Prestidigitation to restore your
hair.)
(Oh, and never switch directly from a publicly-used
disguise back to your true self. Always use a brief generic
disguise in between that's not used for anything other than
getting watchers off your tail. A great way to come up with
new disguises is to pick two people at random and combine or
average features of the two. I remember a game where one
player bragged to me about his street urchins following a
troublesome NPC, and seeing him take off his disguise,
revealing one of the other PCs.)
--index
P.S. - It's amusing what my spell checker wanted to replace
Prestidigitation with...