[sblock=ooc]
If we were sitting at a table playing this game, I'd be having the same conversation with Gandalf. We would have eventually gotten to the RP reasoning.
Yeah, I thought of that. Sort of a table-top discussion informing the IC action rather than the other way around. It could be argued that the OOC is an aide to the player, who isn't the same person as their character, to understanding what their character knows and would do. Makes sense.
Also, Kain suffered 10 cold damage from the mold already, so he knows it's bad news.
I'd forgotten that... good call! However, whether or not Julius is covered in it now, or that it's damaging him, hasn't been communicated.
Also also, you're right - we should be PMing or using the OOC thread for this.
Almost. OOC discussions are fantastic, and actually your spell is a great plan I hadn't thought of (!), I'm just trying to keep up the novel-style of PbP games' IC portions. What you guys did, discussing the plan, was great. What would have made it perfect would have been the IC component.
So basically, do exactly what you guys are doing, but could we please talk about it in IC first *then* post the OOC.
Y'know, I guess it isn't a big deal; I'm just used to being anal about "you know this" and "you don't know this", whether or not it influences actions. [/sblock]