log in or register to remove this ad

 

Player's Guide to Eberron (Book Approval)

Erekose13

Explorer
Player's Guide should also be pretty available now.

So I propose that we allow all new content from the PGoE in. This purposefully excludes all WotC material from other sources that are discussed in the PGoE.

I can provide a complete list of items in this post later if need be.
EDIT: added :)

  • Aerenal Arcanist ( feat , page 20 , Aerenal ) - 2 Yes
  • Aerenal Half-life ( feat , page 20 , Aerenal ) - 2 Yes
  • Aereni Focus ( feat , page 20 , Aerenal ) - 1 Yes, 1 No
  • Create Spirit Idol ( spell , page 21 , Aerenal ) - 2 Yes
  • Bloodtouched Rite ( rite , page 23 , Blood of Vol ) - 1 No
  • Perfect Reflection ( feat , page 25 , Changelings ) - 2 Yes
  • Binding Brand ( feat , page 36 , Demon Wastes ) - 2 Yes
  • Touch of Captivation ( feat , page 35 , Demon Wastes ) - 2 Yes
  • Touch of Deception ( feat , page 35 , Demon Wastes ) - 2 Yes
  • Touch of Summoning ( feat , page 35 , Demon Wastes ) - 2 Yes
  • Documents (many) ( equipment , page 38-41 , Documents ) - 2 Yes
  • Aberrant Dragonmark Gift ( feat , page 49 , Dragonmarks ) - 2 Yes
  • Aberrant Dragonmark Mystery ( feat , page 49 , Dragonmarks ) - 2 Yes
  • Aberrant Dragonmark Vigor ( feat , page 49 , Dragonmarks ) - 2 Yes
  • Dragon's Insight ( feat , page 48 , Dragonmarks ) - 2 Yes
  • Shield of Denieth ( feat , page 48 , Dragonmarks ) - 2 Yes
  • Swiftness of Orien ( feat , page 48 , Dragonmarks ) - 2 Yes
  • Dragonshard Prices ( equipment , page 50 , Dragonshards ) - 2 Yes
  • Bloodstone Blade ( magic item , page 51 , Dragonshards ) - 2 Yes
  • Nightshard Maul ( magic item , page 51 , Dragonshards ) - 2 Yes
  • Ritual of Arcane Opposition ( ritual , page 60 , Eldeen Reaches ) - 2 Yes
  • Ritual of Blight's Embrace ( ritual , page 60 , Eldeen Reaches ) - 2 Yes
  • Ritual of the Timeless Soul ( ritual , page 60 , Eldeen Reaches ) - 2 Yes
  • Ritual of the Woodland Bond ( ritual , page 60 , Eldeen Reaches ) - 2 Yes
  • Artificer's Monocle ( magic item , page 63 , Everyday Magic ) - 2 Yes
  • Unity Wine ( spell , page 73 , Half-elves ) - 2 Yes
  • Friend of the Tribes ( feat , page 75 , Halflings ) - 2 Yes
  • Talenta Dinosaur Bond ( feat , page 75 , Halflings ) - 2 Yes
  • Talenta Drifter ( feat , page 75 , Halflings ) - 2 Yes
  • Galifaran Scholar ( feat , page 77 , History ) - 2 Yes
  • Twinblade Scourge ( magic item , page 79 , Humans ) - 2 Yes
  • Du'ulora Ancestor ( feat , page 83 , Kalashtar ) - 2 Yes
  • Hashalaq Ancestor ( feat , page 83 , Kalashtar ) - 2 Yes
  • Aberration Bane Magic ( feat , page 86 , Khyber ) - 2 Yes
  • Indomitable Discipline ( feat , page 86 , Khyber ) - 2 Yes
  • Unnatural Enemy ( feat , page 86 , Khyber ) - 2 Yes
  • Gatekeeper Mystagogue ( prestige class , page 88 , Khyber ) - 1 Yes
  • High Elemental Binder ( prestige class , page 104 , Magical Traditions ) - 2 Yes (with clarification)
  • Sudden Willow Strike ( feat , page 109 , Monastic Traditions ) - 2 Yes
  • Cyrite ( material , page 117 , Mournland ) - 1 Yes
  • Child of the Swamps ( feat , page 119 , Orcs ) - 2 Yes
  • Battlebred ( feat , page 122 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
  • Chosen of the Deathless ( feat , page 122 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
  • Manifest Druid ( feat , page 122 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
Note: All of the following require membership in the Manifest Spellshapers (should be in a PCs background and requires the mark of justice as specified on pg. 124)
  • Mastery of Chaos and Order ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
  • Mastery of Day and Night ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence ) - 2 Yes
  • Mastery of Dreams ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
  • Mastery of Faerie Enchantment ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
  • Mastery of Ice and Fire ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
  • Mastery of Madness ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
  • Mastery of the Azure Sky ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
  • Mastery of the Battleground ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
  • Mastery of the Dead ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
  • Mastery of the Mists ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
  • Mastery of the Silver Void ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
  • Mastery of Twilight Denizens ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
  • Mastery of Twisted Shadow ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
  • Jungle Juice ( equipment , page 129 , Q'Barra ) - 2 Yes
  • Shifter Acrobatics ( feat , page 135 , Shifters ) - 3 Yes
  • Shifter Magnetism ( feat , page 135 , Shifters ) - 3 Yes
  • Shifter Stealth ( feat , page 135 , Shifters ) - 3 Yes
  • Bladebearer of the Valenar ( feat , page 141 , Valenar ) - Already in RoE
  • Shield of Blades ( feat , page 141 , Valenar ) - 2 Yes
  • Spirit of the Stallion ( feat , page 141 , Valenar ) - 2 Yes
  • Valenar Trample ( feat , page 141 , Valenar ) - 1 Yes
  • Zaelshin Tu ( magic item , page 145 , Valenar ) - 1 Yes
  • Revenant Blade ( prestige class , page 142 , Valenar ) - 1 Yes
  • Death's Blood ( feat , page 149 , Villainous Organizations ) - 2 Yes
  • Blade of Light ( power , page 149 , Villainous Organizations ) - 2 Yes
  • Dissonant Touch ( power , page 149 , Villainous Organizations ) - 2 Yes
  • Price of Loyalty ( spell , page 149 , Villainous Organizations ) - 2 Yes
  • Sentinel's Watch ( spell , page 149 , Villainous Organizations ) - 2 Yes
  • Overload Metabolism ( feat , page 151 , Warforged ) - 2 Yes
  • Shocking Fist ( feat , page 151 , Warforged ) - 2 Yes

[sblock=by type]EQUIPMENT
  • Documents (many) ( equipment , page 38-41 , Documents )
  • Dragonshard Prices ( equipment , page 50 , Dragonshards )
  • Jungle Juice ( equipment , page 129 , Q'Barra )

FEATS
  • Aberrant Dragonmark Gift ( feat , page 49 , Dragonmarks )
  • Aberrant Dragonmark Mystery ( feat , page 49 , Dragonmarks )
  • Aberrant Dragonmark Vigor ( feat , page 49 , Dragonmarks )
  • Aberration Bane Magic ( feat , page 86 , Khyber )
  • Aerenal Arcanist ( feat , page 20 , Aerenal )
  • Aerenal Half-life ( feat , page 20 , Aerenal )
  • Aereni Focus ( feat , page 20 , Aerenal )
  • Battlebred ( feat , page 122 , Planes of Existence )
  • Binding Brand ( feat , page 36 , Demon Wastes )
  • Bladebearer of the Valenra ( feat , page 141 , Valenar )
  • Child of the Swamps ( feat , page 119 , Orcs )
  • Chosen of the Deathless ( feat , page 122 , Planes of Existence )
  • Death's Blood ( feat , page 149 , Villainous Organizations )
  • Dragon's Insight ( feat , page 48 , Dragonmarks )
  • Du'ulora Ancestor ( feat , page 83 , Kalashtar )
  • Friend of the Tribes ( feat , page 75 , Halflings )
  • Galifaran Scholar ( feat , page 77 , History )
  • Hashalaq Ancestor ( feat , page 83 , Kalashtar )
  • Indomitable Discipline ( feat , page 86 , Khyber )
  • Manifest Druid ( feat , page 122 , Planes of Existence )
  • Mastery of Chaos and Order ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
  • Mastery of Day and Night ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
  • Mastery of Dreams ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
  • Mastery of Faerie Enchantment ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
  • Mastery of Ice and Fire ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
  • Mastery of Madness ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
  • Mastery of the Azure Sky ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
  • Mastery of the Battleground ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
  • Mastery of the Dead ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
  • Mastery of the Mists ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
  • Mastery of the Silver Void ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
  • Mastery of Twilight Denizens ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
  • Mastery of Twisted Shadow ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
  • Overload Metabolism ( feat , page 151 , Warforged )
  • Perfect Reflection ( feat , page 25 , Changelings )
  • Shield of Blades ( feat , page 141 , Valenar )
  • Shield of Denieth ( feat , page 48 , Dragonmarks )
  • Shifter Acrobatics ( feat , page 135 , Shifters )
  • Shifter Magnetism ( feat , page 135 , Shifters )
  • Shifter Stealth ( feat , page 135 , Shifters )
  • Shocking Fist ( feat , page 151 , Warforged )
  • Spirit of the Stallion ( feat , page 141 , Valenar )
  • Sudden Willow Strike ( feat , page 109 , Monastic Traditions )
  • Swiftness of Orien ( feat , page 48 , Dragonmarks )
  • Talenta Dinosaur Bond ( feat , page 75 , Halflings )
  • Talenta Drifter ( feat , page 75 , Halflings )
  • Touch of Captivation ( feat , page 35 , Demon Wastes )
  • Touch of Deception ( feat , page 35 , Demon Wastes )
  • Touch of Summoning ( feat , page 35 , Demon Wastes )
  • Unnatural Enemy ( feat , page 86 , Khyber )
  • Valenar Trample ( feat , page 141 , Valenar )

MAGIC ITEMS
  • Artificer's Monocle ( magic item , page 63 , Everyday Magic )
  • Bloodstone Blade ( magic item , page 51 , Dragonshards )
  • Nightshard Maul ( magic item , page 51 , Dragonshards )
  • Twinblade Scourge ( magic item , page 79 , Humans )
  • Zaelshin Tu ( magic item , page 145 , Valenar )

MATERIAL
  • Cyrite ( material , page 117 , Mournland )

POWER
  • Blade of Light ( power , page 149 , Villainous Organizations )
  • Dissonant Touch ( power , page 149 , Villainous Organizations )

PRESTIGE CLASSES
  • Gatekeeper Mystagogue ( prestige class , page 88 , Khyber )
  • High Elemental Binder ( prestige class , page 104 , Magical Traditions )
  • Revenant Blade ( prestige class , page 142 , Valenar )

RITUALS
  • Bloodtouched Rite ( ritual , page 23 , Blood of Vol )
  • Ritual of Arcane Opposition ( ritual , page 60 , Eldeen Reaches )
  • Ritual of Blight's Embrace ( ritual , page 60 , Eldeen Reaches )
  • Ritual of the Timeless Soul ( ritual , page 60 , Eldeen Reaches )
  • Ritual of the Woodland Bond ( ritual , page 60 , Eldeen Reaches )

SPELLS
  • Create Spirit Idol ( spell , page 21 , Aerenal )
  • Price of Loyalty ( spell , page 149 , Villainous Organizations )
  • Sentinel's Watch ( spell , page 149 , Villainous Organizations )
  • Unity Wine ( spell , page 73 , Half-elves )
[/sblock]
 
Last edited:

log in or register to remove this ad

stonegod

Spawn of Khyber/LEB Judge
PGtE has a *lot* of bits and pieces spread all over the place. It'd take a bit to look at them all. I'd more inclined for a bit-by-bit approach unless the other judges have a strong opinion otherwise.

(Note, we are already using the Elan justification from PGtE).
 

Erekose13

Explorer
Yup there is a lot in there... My excel file came up to 74 lines. The big chunk is feats and there are a few in there that are questionable. How do we want to approach this? I divied it up by type of item, I could easily do it alphabetically or by section/page.

Regarding the outside sources, yup I know about the Elan. But I figured that I would leave all that out of the discussion for this book and more to individual proposals for the original books. Less clutter here and more focus on the new stuff.
 



Erekose13

Explorer
All of it is in sidebars, but yeah theres a heck of a lot. In addition to all the stuff listed it tells you how you could incorporate a lot of different material from other WotC sources like CompArc and CompDiv all the way along to Magic of Incarnum and Heroes of Battle.
 

Bront

The man with the probe
I vote YES to:
Shifter Acrobatics ( feat , page 135 , Shifters )
Shifter Magnetism ( feat , page 135 , Shifters )
Shifter Stealth ( feat , page 135 , Shifters )


Battlebred ( feat , page 122 , Planes of Existence )
Manifest Druid ( feat , page 122 , Planes of Existence )
Chosen of the Deathless ( feat , page 122 , Planes of Existence )

Mastery of Chaos and Order ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
Mastery of Day and Night ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
Mastery of Dreams ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
Mastery of Faerie Enchantment ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
Mastery of Ice and Fire ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
Mastery of Madness ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
Mastery of the Azure Sky ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
Mastery of the Battleground ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
Mastery of the Dead ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
Mastery of the Mists ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
Mastery of the Silver Void ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
Mastery of Twilight Denizens ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
Mastery of Twisted Shadow ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )

Still looking around, but I've read up on those at least. Mostly flavorful stuff, and usefull in limited capacity.
 
Last edited:








Bront

The man with the probe
LogicsFate said:
Ooo more Shifter feats, they usefull at all?
Meh, they're ok. Some are all the time, some are only durring shifting. There are better ones, but there are much worse ones too.
 



Rystil Arden

First Post
Erekose13 said:
Given that this is a book approval and not personally created stuff, can I vote too?
I'd say yes, but I'm not sure. Anyway, I realised I actually grabbed this one from my little brother last time I was home, so I looked at the Shifter feats and they don't seem abusable in any way. I'll YES those three at least, but not enough time to look at the whole thing, especially since the layout makes it terribly hard to find stuff (the Shifter feats required looking at the index for Shifters and then guessing until I found the right entry).
 


stonegod

Spawn of Khyber/LEB Judge
The following are YES
  • Aerenal Arcanist ( feat , page 20 , Aerenal )
  • Aerenal Half-life ( feat , page 20 , Aerenal )
  • Aereni Focus ( feat , page 20 , Aerenal )
  • Create Spirit Idol ( spell , page 21 , Aerenal )
  • Perfect Reflection ( feat , page 25 , Changelings )
  • Binding Brand ( feat , page 36 , Demon Wastes )
  • Touch of Captivation ( feat , page 35 , Demon Wastes )
  • Touch of Deception ( feat , page 35 , Demon Wastes )
  • Touch of Summoning ( feat , page 35 , Demon Wastes )
  • Documents (many) ( equipment , page 38-41 , Documents )
  • Aberrant Dragonmark Gift ( feat , page 49 , Dragonmarks )
  • Aberrant Dragonmark Mystery ( feat , page 49 , Dragonmarks )
  • Aberrant Dragonmark Vigor ( feat , page 49 , Dragonmarks )
  • Dragon's Insight ( feat , page 48 , Dragonmarks )
  • Shield of Denieth ( feat , page 48 , Dragonmarks )
  • Swiftness of Orien ( feat , page 48 , Dragonmarks )
  • Dragonshard Prices ( equipment , page 50 , Dragonshards )
  • Bloodstone Blade ( magic item , page 51 , Dragonshards )
  • Nightshard Maul ( magic item , page 51 , Dragonshards )
  • Ritual of Arcane Opposition ( ritual , page 60 , Eldeen Reaches )
  • Ritual of Blight's Embrace ( ritual , page 60 , Eldeen Reaches )
  • Ritual of the Timeless Soul ( ritual , page 60 , Eldeen Reaches )
  • Ritual of the Woodland Bond ( ritual , page 60 , Eldeen Reaches )
  • Artificer's Monocle ( magic item , page 63 , Everyday Magic )
  • Unity Wine ( spell , page 73 , Half-elves )
  • Friend of the Tribes ( feat , page 75 , Halflings )
  • Talenta Dinosaur Bond ( feat , page 75 , Halflings )
  • Talenta Drifter ( feat , page 75 , Halflings )
  • Galifaran Scholar ( feat , page 77 , History )
  • Twinblade Scourge ( magic item , page 79 , Humans )
  • Du'ulora Ancestor ( feat , page 83 , Kalashtar )
  • Hashalaq Ancestor ( feat , page 83 , Kalashtar )
  • Aberration Bane Magic ( feat , page 86 , Khyber )
  • Indomitable Discipline ( feat , page 86 , Khyber )
  • Unnatural Enemy ( feat , page 86 , Khyber )
  • Gatekeeper Mystagogue ( prestige class , page 88 , Khyber )
  • Sudden Willow Strike ( feat , page 109 , Monastic Traditions )
  • Child of the Swamps ( feat , page 119 , Orcs )
  • Battlebred ( feat , page 122 , Planes of Existence )
  • Chosen of the Deathless ( feat , page 122 , Planes of Existence )
  • Manifest Druid ( feat , page 122 , Planes of Existence )
  • Jungle Juice ( equipment , page 129 , Q'Barra ): I already proposed these, but no one voted IIRC.
  • Shifter Acrobatics ( feat , page 135 , Shifters )
  • Shifter Magnetism ( feat , page 135 , Shifters )
  • Shifter Stealth ( feat , page 135 , Shifters )
  • Bladebearer of the Valenra ( feat , page 141 , Valenar ): Already approved IIRC
  • Shield of Blades ( feat , page 141 , Valenar )
  • Spirit of the Stallion ( feat , page 141 , Valenar )
  • Valenar Trample ( feat , page 141 , Valenar )
  • Zaelshin Tu ( magic item , page 145 , Valenar )
  • Revenant Blade ( prestige class , page 142 , Valenar )
  • Death's Blood ( feat , page 149 , Villainous Organizations )
  • Blade of Light ( power , page 149 , Villainous Organizations )
  • Dissonant Touch ( power , page 149 , Villainous Organizations )
  • Price of Loyalty ( spell , page 149 , Villainous Organizations )
  • Sentinel's Watch ( spell , page 149 , Villainous Organizations )
  • Overload Metabolism ( feat , page 151 , Warforged )
  • Shocking Fist ( feat , page 151 , Warforged )

YES but with clarification:
  • Bloodtouched Rite ( rite , page 23 , Blood of Vol ): Once only.
  • High Elemental Binder ( prestige class , page 104 , Magical Traditions ): Though you can have multiple companions, only one can be summoned per day.
  • Cyrite ( material , page 117 , Mournland ): Might be a bit too cheap.
  • All of the following require membership in the Manifest Spellshapers (should be in a PCs background and requires the mark of justice as specified on pg. 124):
    • Mastery of Chaos and Order ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
    • Mastery of Day and Night ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
    • Mastery of Dreams ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
    • Mastery of Faerie Enchantment ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
    • Mastery of Ice and Fire ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
    • Mastery of Madness ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
    • Mastery of the Azure Sky ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
    • Mastery of the Battleground ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
    • Mastery of the Dead ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence ): As HD grows rapidly, should not be a huge problem.
    • Mastery of the Mists ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
    • Mastery of the Silver Void ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
    • Mastery of Twilight Denizens ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
    • Mastery of Twisted Shadow ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
 

An Advertisement

Advertisement4

Top