Player's Guide to Eberron (Book Approval)

[Erekose13]

Player's Guide should also be pretty available now.

So I propose that we allow all new content from the PGoE in. This purposefully excludes all WotC material from other sources that are discussed in the PGoE.

I can provide a complete list of items in this post later if need be.
EDIT: added

• Aerenal Arcanist ( feat , page 20 , Aerenal ) - 2 Yes
• Aerenal Half-life ( feat , page 20 , Aerenal ) - 2 Yes
• Aereni Focus ( feat , page 20 , Aerenal ) - 1 Yes, 1 No
• Create Spirit Idol ( spell , page 21 , Aerenal ) - 2 Yes
• Bloodtouched Rite ( rite , page 23 , Blood of Vol ) - 1 No
• Perfect Reflection ( feat , page 25 , Changelings ) - 2 Yes
• Binding Brand ( feat , page 36 , Demon Wastes ) - 2 Yes
• Touch of Captivation ( feat , page 35 , Demon Wastes ) - 2 Yes
• Touch of Deception ( feat , page 35 , Demon Wastes ) - 2 Yes
• Touch of Summoning ( feat , page 35 , Demon Wastes ) - 2 Yes
• Documents (many) ( equipment , page 38-41 , Documents ) - 2 Yes
• Aberrant Dragonmark Gift ( feat , page 49 , Dragonmarks ) - 2 Yes
• Aberrant Dragonmark Mystery ( feat , page 49 , Dragonmarks ) - 2 Yes
• Aberrant Dragonmark Vigor ( feat , page 49 , Dragonmarks ) - 2 Yes
• Dragon's Insight ( feat , page 48 , Dragonmarks ) - 2 Yes
• Shield of Denieth ( feat , page 48 , Dragonmarks ) - 2 Yes
• Swiftness of Orien ( feat , page 48 , Dragonmarks ) - 2 Yes
• Dragonshard Prices ( equipment , page 50 , Dragonshards ) - 2 Yes
• Bloodstone Blade ( magic item , page 51 , Dragonshards ) - 2 Yes
• Nightshard Maul ( magic item , page 51 , Dragonshards ) - 2 Yes
• Ritual of Arcane Opposition ( ritual , page 60 , Eldeen Reaches ) - 2 Yes
• Ritual of Blight's Embrace ( ritual , page 60 , Eldeen Reaches ) - 2 Yes
• Ritual of the Timeless Soul ( ritual , page 60 , Eldeen Reaches ) - 2 Yes
• Ritual of the Woodland Bond ( ritual , page 60 , Eldeen Reaches ) - 2 Yes
• Artificer's Monocle ( magic item , page 63 , Everyday Magic ) - 2 Yes
• Unity Wine ( spell , page 73 , Half-elves ) - 2 Yes
• Friend of the Tribes ( feat , page 75 , Halflings ) - 2 Yes
• Talenta Dinosaur Bond ( feat , page 75 , Halflings ) - 2 Yes
• Talenta Drifter ( feat , page 75 , Halflings ) - 2 Yes
• Galifaran Scholar ( feat , page 77 , History ) - 2 Yes
• Twinblade Scourge ( magic item , page 79 , Humans ) - 2 Yes
• Du'ulora Ancestor ( feat , page 83 , Kalashtar ) - 2 Yes
• Hashalaq Ancestor ( feat , page 83 , Kalashtar ) - 2 Yes
• Aberration Bane Magic ( feat , page 86 , Khyber ) - 2 Yes
• Indomitable Discipline ( feat , page 86 , Khyber ) - 2 Yes
• Unnatural Enemy ( feat , page 86 , Khyber ) - 2 Yes
• Gatekeeper Mystagogue ( prestige class , page 88 , Khyber ) - 1 Yes
• High Elemental Binder ( prestige class , page 104 , Magical Traditions ) - 2 Yes (with clarification)
• Sudden Willow Strike ( feat , page 109 , Monastic Traditions ) - 2 Yes
• Cyrite ( material , page 117 , Mournland ) - 1 Yes
• Child of the Swamps ( feat , page 119 , Orcs ) - 2 Yes
• Battlebred ( feat , page 122 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
• Chosen of the Deathless ( feat , page 122 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
• Manifest Druid ( feat , page 122 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes

Note: All of the following require membership in the Manifest Spellshapers (should be in a PCs background and requires the mark of justice as specified on pg. 124)

• Mastery of Chaos and Order ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
• Mastery of Day and Night ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence ) - 2 Yes
• Mastery of Dreams ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
• Mastery of Faerie Enchantment ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
• Mastery of Ice and Fire ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
• Mastery of Madness ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
• Mastery of the Azure Sky ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
• Mastery of the Battleground ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
• Mastery of the Dead ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
• Mastery of the Mists ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
• Mastery of the Silver Void ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
• Mastery of Twilight Denizens ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes
• Mastery of Twisted Shadow ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence ) - 3 Yes

• Jungle Juice ( equipment , page 129 , Q'Barra ) - 2 Yes
• Shifter Acrobatics ( feat , page 135 , Shifters ) - 3 Yes
• Shifter Magnetism ( feat , page 135 , Shifters ) - 3 Yes
• Shifter Stealth ( feat , page 135 , Shifters ) - 3 Yes
• Bladebearer of the Valenar ( feat , page 141 , Valenar ) - Already in RoE
• Shield of Blades ( feat , page 141 , Valenar ) - 2 Yes
• Spirit of the Stallion ( feat , page 141 , Valenar ) - 2 Yes
• Valenar Trample ( feat , page 141 , Valenar ) - 1 Yes
• Zaelshin Tu ( magic item , page 145 , Valenar ) - 1 Yes
• Revenant Blade ( prestige class , page 142 , Valenar ) - 1 Yes
• Death's Blood ( feat , page 149 , Villainous Organizations ) - 2 Yes
• Blade of Light ( power , page 149 , Villainous Organizations ) - 2 Yes
• Dissonant Touch ( power , page 149 , Villainous Organizations ) - 2 Yes
• Price of Loyalty ( spell , page 149 , Villainous Organizations ) - 2 Yes
• Sentinel's Watch ( spell , page 149 , Villainous Organizations ) - 2 Yes
• Overload Metabolism ( feat , page 151 , Warforged ) - 2 Yes
• Shocking Fist ( feat , page 151 , Warforged ) - 2 Yes

[sblock=by type]EQUIPMENT

• Documents (many) ( equipment , page 38-41 , Documents )
• Dragonshard Prices ( equipment , page 50 , Dragonshards )
• Jungle Juice ( equipment , page 129 , Q'Barra )

FEATS

• Aberrant Dragonmark Gift ( feat , page 49 , Dragonmarks )
• Aberrant Dragonmark Mystery ( feat , page 49 , Dragonmarks )
• Aberrant Dragonmark Vigor ( feat , page 49 , Dragonmarks )
• Aberration Bane Magic ( feat , page 86 , Khyber )
• Aerenal Arcanist ( feat , page 20 , Aerenal )
• Aerenal Half-life ( feat , page 20 , Aerenal )
• Aereni Focus ( feat , page 20 , Aerenal )
• Battlebred ( feat , page 122 , Planes of Existence )
• Binding Brand ( feat , page 36 , Demon Wastes )
• Bladebearer of the Valenra ( feat , page 141 , Valenar )
• Child of the Swamps ( feat , page 119 , Orcs )
• Chosen of the Deathless ( feat , page 122 , Planes of Existence )
• Death's Blood ( feat , page 149 , Villainous Organizations )
• Dragon's Insight ( feat , page 48 , Dragonmarks )
• Du'ulora Ancestor ( feat , page 83 , Kalashtar )
• Friend of the Tribes ( feat , page 75 , Halflings )
• Galifaran Scholar ( feat , page 77 , History )
• Hashalaq Ancestor ( feat , page 83 , Kalashtar )
• Indomitable Discipline ( feat , page 86 , Khyber )
• Manifest Druid ( feat , page 122 , Planes of Existence )
• Mastery of Chaos and Order ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
• Mastery of Day and Night ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
• Mastery of Dreams ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
• Mastery of Faerie Enchantment ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
• Mastery of Ice and Fire ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
• Mastery of Madness ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
• Mastery of the Azure Sky ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
• Mastery of the Battleground ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
• Mastery of the Dead ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
• Mastery of the Mists ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
• Mastery of the Silver Void ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
• Mastery of Twilight Denizens ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
• Mastery of Twisted Shadow ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
• Overload Metabolism ( feat , page 151 , Warforged )
• Perfect Reflection ( feat , page 25 , Changelings )
• Shield of Blades ( feat , page 141 , Valenar )
• Shield of Denieth ( feat , page 48 , Dragonmarks )
• Shifter Acrobatics ( feat , page 135 , Shifters )
• Shifter Magnetism ( feat , page 135 , Shifters )
• Shifter Stealth ( feat , page 135 , Shifters )
• Shocking Fist ( feat , page 151 , Warforged )
• Spirit of the Stallion ( feat , page 141 , Valenar )
• Sudden Willow Strike ( feat , page 109 , Monastic Traditions )
• Swiftness of Orien ( feat , page 48 , Dragonmarks )
• Talenta Dinosaur Bond ( feat , page 75 , Halflings )
• Talenta Drifter ( feat , page 75 , Halflings )
• Touch of Captivation ( feat , page 35 , Demon Wastes )
• Touch of Deception ( feat , page 35 , Demon Wastes )
• Touch of Summoning ( feat , page 35 , Demon Wastes )
• Unnatural Enemy ( feat , page 86 , Khyber )
• Valenar Trample ( feat , page 141 , Valenar )

MAGIC ITEMS

• Artificer's Monocle ( magic item , page 63 , Everyday Magic )
• Bloodstone Blade ( magic item , page 51 , Dragonshards )
• Nightshard Maul ( magic item , page 51 , Dragonshards )
• Twinblade Scourge ( magic item , page 79 , Humans )
• Zaelshin Tu ( magic item , page 145 , Valenar )

MATERIAL

• Cyrite ( material , page 117 , Mournland )

POWER

• Blade of Light ( power , page 149 , Villainous Organizations )
• Dissonant Touch ( power , page 149 , Villainous Organizations )

PRESTIGE CLASSES

• Gatekeeper Mystagogue ( prestige class , page 88 , Khyber )
• High Elemental Binder ( prestige class , page 104 , Magical Traditions )
• Revenant Blade ( prestige class , page 142 , Valenar )

RITUALS

• Bloodtouched Rite ( ritual , page 23 , Blood of Vol )
• Ritual of Arcane Opposition ( ritual , page 60 , Eldeen Reaches )
• Ritual of Blight's Embrace ( ritual , page 60 , Eldeen Reaches )
• Ritual of the Timeless Soul ( ritual , page 60 , Eldeen Reaches )
• Ritual of the Woodland Bond ( ritual , page 60 , Eldeen Reaches )

SPELLS

• Create Spirit Idol ( spell , page 21 , Aerenal )
• Price of Loyalty ( spell , page 149 , Villainous Organizations )
• Sentinel's Watch ( spell , page 149 , Villainous Organizations )
• Unity Wine ( spell , page 73 , Half-elves )

[/sblock]

 

[stonegod]

PGtE has a *lot* of bits and pieces spread all over the place. It'd take a bit to look at them all. I'd more inclined for a bit-by-bit approach unless the other judges have a strong opinion otherwise.

(Note, we are already using the Elan justification from PGtE).

 

[Erekose13]

Yup there is a lot in there... My excel file came up to 74 lines. The big chunk is feats and there are a few in there that are questionable. How do we want to approach this? I divied it up by type of item, I could easily do it alphabetically or by section/page.

Regarding the outside sources, yup I know about the Elan. But I figured that I would leave all that out of the discussion for this book and more to individual proposals for the original books. Less clutter here and more focus on the new stuff.

 

[Bront]

Wow, I didn't know there was anything in this book crunch wise.

 

[Bront]

Bladebearer of the Valenar ( feat , page 141 , Valenar ) - Already approved in RoE

 

[Erekose13]

All of it is in sidebars, but yeah theres a heck of a lot. In addition to all the stuff listed it tells you how you could incorporate a lot of different material from other WotC sources like CompArc and CompDiv all the way along to Magic of Incarnum and Heroes of Battle.

 

[Bront]

I vote YES to:
Shifter Acrobatics ( feat , page 135 , Shifters )
Shifter Magnetism ( feat , page 135 , Shifters )
Shifter Stealth ( feat , page 135 , Shifters )


Battlebred ( feat , page 122 , Planes of Existence )
Manifest Druid ( feat , page 122 , Planes of Existence )
Chosen of the Deathless ( feat , page 122 , Planes of Existence )

Mastery of Chaos and Order ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
Mastery of Day and Night ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
Mastery of Dreams ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
Mastery of Faerie Enchantment ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
Mastery of Ice and Fire ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
Mastery of Madness ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
Mastery of the Azure Sky ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
Mastery of the Battleground ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
Mastery of the Dead ( feat , page 125 , Planes of Existence )
Mastery of the Mists ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
Mastery of the Silver Void ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
Mastery of Twilight Denizens ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )
Mastery of Twisted Shadow ( feat , page 126 , Planes of Existence )

Still looking around, but I've read up on those at least. Mostly flavorful stuff, and usefull in limited capacity.

 

[Erekose13]

would it help at all to reorganize my list by section rather than type of benefit?

 

[Bront]

would it help at all to reorganize my list by section rather than type of benefit?

Yes

 

[Erekose13]

Will do, my excel doc is at work, so it'll be tomorrow.