*Plunk* Thread Closed.

WanderingMonster

First Post
I hate to say it, but few things ique my interest more than fresh baked pumpkin pie, my lady beckoning me with that come-hither voice, and threads that have been closed...

I think the reason for the latter is obvious: rubbernecking (or whatever the message board equivalent is). We know we're not supposed to enjoy it, or find it entertaining, but that locked-thread icon is the forbidden fruit and I long for secret knowledge.

So being a fan of closed threads, I must say that I've become an afficianado of moderator shut-down technique. PC's is my favorite. Maybe it's the sheer volume of his thread closure, but it's at least partly due to the voice that I attribute to his closing posts. Unlike the majority of ENworlders, I've had the luxury of meeting PC (albeit once...nearly three years ago...for, like, an hour or two). Imagine the nicest person you know. Now imagine how that person gets when irritated (or what it takes to irritate that person). So to me, I read PC's closures as always followed by an exasperated sigh, followed by regret that everyone can't just play nicely.

Sadly...this is entertaining to me. Yes, yes. I know--I have no life.

There's something to be said for other techniques. I appreciate the "fireman" technique you sometimes see with Henry or DinkleDog. Squelching individual offensive posts of their...er...offensiveness before extinguishing the whole thread. You might also call this the "Nothing to see here" technique.

Eric's method just reminds me of the kind of firm response you'd give a dog for chewing your shoe: "Ah-ah-ah! Hey now..." Also entertaining.

So what's the best "thread closed" post you've seen? Mods, what trade secrets can you share with us? Who's the dreamiest thread-squashing mod?
 

log in or register to remove this ad

I think PC's got the best technique. Poor Eric frets for days over whether or not he's too heavy-handed. My secret is to close the thread and then write the thread-closing comment, then leave it open for about 10 minutes and browse pictures of puppies and kittens. Then I come back and read it before I hit submit. Helps to keep me from being too snippy.
 


I have to admit that when I see a closed thread, I always find myself compelled to go and see what got it closed...and who. Just for entertainment, you understand :)
 

Tallarn said:
I have to admit that when I see a closed thread, I always find myself compelled to go and see what got it closed...and who. Just for entertainment, you understand :)

And I thought I was the only one with that vice...
 


I'd like to bring a couple of Coup de Graces up for critique. Please be honest, it's for posterity. First up is...

avatar.php

"Babes of Gencon Gallery" thread
Bored now.

Thread closed.


This has it all. The use of terse sentence fragments tells us that Morrus obviously doesn't think this thread is worth his time. He takes the stance of a regent who has lost interest in the bufoons prancing about for his pleasure. I expect a look of sheepish bewilderment from the entertainers as they pack up their puppets and juggling balls and slink out of their irate master's view lest he call the guard uopn them. It's alliterative as well, almost like verse. It's this kind of plunk that brings tears to my eyes. I give it a solid 8

Please comment on the above, add your thoughts, and finally rate it on a scale of 1-10 (One having the least flair, and ten having a plethora of panache). Remember, we're not questioning why they closed a thread...but their technique.
 

WanderingMonster said:
This has it all. The use of terse sentence fragments tells us that Morrus obviously doesn't think this thread is worth his time. He takes the stance of a regent who has lost interest in the bufoons prancing about for his pleasure. I expect a look of sheepish bewilderment from the entertainers as they pack up their puppets and juggling balls and slink out of their irate master's view lest he call the guard uopn them. It's alliterative as well, almost like verse. It's this kind of plunk that brings tears to my eyes. I give it a solid 8

Please comment on the above, add your thoughts, and finally rate it on a scale of 1-10 (One having the least flair, and ten having a plethora of panache). Remember, we're not questioning why they closed a thread...but their technique.
ROFL, I dunno about Morrus' thread closure, but I give your post a 10. :D
 



Remove ads

Top