abyssaldeath
First Post
Statistically that may be true, but it's much more exiting to reroll a 1 because of the chance to roll max no matter how remote.
Heck, you could have just made it 3d4.
It should be a d10+2.
Because it gives you a second chance to roll max.
Rerolling is fine, but honestly, I'd just take the shortcut of rolling once. I know we have some players who would be rolling that 1d12 like a half dozen times. 1d10+2 gets you to the same place faster. If it makes you feel better, grab a d10, and pencil in a 1 in front of the 1 and the 2. Voila, no more 1's and 2's.
Rerolling is fine, but honestly, I'd just take the shortcut of rolling once. I know we have some players who would be rolling that 1d12 like a half dozen times. 1d10+2 gets you to the same place faster. If it makes you feel better, grab a d10, and pencil in a 1 in front of the 1 and the 2. Voila, no more 1's and 2's.
I'm only half joking. I wonder how long it will be before a dice company comes out with brutal dice sets.
changing 1 to 11 and 2 to 12 would make for a much more powerful weapon than just rerolling 1's and 2's. since rerolling a 1 could give you any result from 3-12 (avg 8.5) and the same with a 2, as opposed to a definate 11 or 12