Oni
First Post
Just to clarify what I just posted. That all together isn't meant to be a proposal per say. I think we'd be better off if things where voted up or down one item at a time rather than as a package.
Some thoughts on approach. If we're to alter rules, simplicity is something to keep in mind. The more rules changes you make that have to be kept in mind the more cumbersome it becomes. So I think in most cases it's just easier to completely remove something than try to fix it. Somethings have an interesting enough flavor that they're worth preserving in some fashion (for instance I like the idea of Bloodclaw weapons enough to want to fix them rather than get rid of them).
So in regards to my own changes it may in fact just be easier to ban Bloodclaw and RoB than altering them since we're dealing with a large pool of players rather than a few people at a home game where the changes don't effect so many people so as to create headaches in character creation and approval.
Some thoughts on approach. If we're to alter rules, simplicity is something to keep in mind. The more rules changes you make that have to be kept in mind the more cumbersome it becomes. So I think in most cases it's just easier to completely remove something than try to fix it. Somethings have an interesting enough flavor that they're worth preserving in some fashion (for instance I like the idea of Bloodclaw weapons enough to want to fix them rather than get rid of them).
So in regards to my own changes it may in fact just be easier to ban Bloodclaw and RoB than altering them since we're dealing with a large pool of players rather than a few people at a home game where the changes don't effect so many people so as to create headaches in character creation and approval.