Cergorach said:
He did Hercules and Xena, I really hope it isn't 'that' quality! While being fun in their own way, it isn't the way I would like to depict the fantasy genre to the masses. More grim, less commical...
horacethegrey said:
I'm pretty sure Raimi's smart enough to realize that the Hercules and Xena formula won't cut it in this day and age of Battlestar Galactica
First off, while it's true that Hercules was targeted at younger viewers, Xena definitely had episodes that were extremely grim--torture, mutilation, mass slaughter of innocents, you name it. It also had comical episodes, but contrary to popular assertions the two can be mixed (q.v. Shakespeare), and it's to the show's credit that it was able to demonstrate influences from across the spectrum of fiction. Battlestar Galactica is boring exactly because the show adopts such a dour, grey face all of the time.
Secondly, don't kid yourselves. this "day and age" is no different from any previous day and age. Yeah, we got Battlestar Galactica (for whatever that's worth), but we also have Flash Gordon. And I'd put Supernatural and Smallville (neither of which could be accused of being aimed solely at really smart people) in the same league as Herc and Xena when it comes to dialogue and plotting.
Ranger REG said:
Any doubt? Before
Spider-Man, he's responsible for bringing
Hercules: The Legendary Journey (with Kevin Sorbo) and
Xena: Warrior Princess to the small screen.
Sometimes you just can't escape your past, especially those who remembers them.
He's got nothing to escape from. The shows had long, successful runs and good episodes. Do you also call the original Star Trek (with William Shatner, winner of two Golden Raspberry awards) a flop just because it had some cheesy production values some episodes with bad plots? Sorry, it too is a classic.
Mark said:
The spiderman movies proved he could handle the darker tones, as did many moments in later Xena storylines.
Again, we are talking about a guy who, like Peter Jackson, got his start doing horror movies. Darkman, The Quick and The Dead, A Simple Plan...all pretty dark.