Parmandur
Book-Friend, he/him
Right and it works because D&D is a pretty forgiving system that can take a lot.The goal isn’t to be perfect. It’s to be good enough.
Right and it works because D&D is a pretty forgiving system that can take a lot.The goal isn’t to be perfect. It’s to be good enough.
Indeed. With private, official playtesting they have a clear idea of what conditions it was playtested under, and know the data is reliable. With public submissions, they have no idea what scenario you put it through. They have no idea if you misread or misunderstood the material. They have no idea if you're fibbing about having playtested it and are just going off a cold read and vibes.As has been mentioned, Public playtesting is made for (mostly) free market research and to get the general “yes or no” vibe to big ideas. The more nuanced feedback comes from private playtesters, because it’s easier to process the notes of 20 people on the 100+ spells they are testing than it would be for them to comb through the hundreds of UA responses.
Piggybacking off this, the reason they are holding off on announcing DS currently is that they are going to make it a BIG DEAL kind of announcement. It's introducing the 15th official class into the game. They are bringing back the last major Classic setting. And I think they a.) want this to be a huge event on it's own and b.) didn't want it overshadowing Ravenloft and Arcana Unleashed. They are going to make a huge marketing push out of this in the end of the year.Last off topic post I’ll make, but there’s little to no chance the Champions book is Dragonlance or a Martial Champions book.
They held the announcement back for a later reveal. Likely at something like GaryCon or maybe even GenCon. That means they think it’s a big announcement that would generate buzz, and was worth giving its own platform. Dragonlance is cool, but it isn’t one of their biggest settings.
Their big 5 settings have, for the past two decades, been Faerun, Ravenloft, Eberron, Planescape, and Dark Sun. Only one of those hasn’t seen a release in the 5e era.
I fully expect the December book announcement to be Dark Sun. We’ve seen it tested in UA multiple times, they refreshed their trademarks on the product, and it fits the more setting forward approach that both late 5e and early 5.5e have taken.
Exactly! If it isn’t Dark Sun, then this is a major Marketing blunder to me. The only possible book that would warrant the same treatment is a fully revised Tasha’s and Xanathar’s book but I don’t think that’s happening anymore.Piggybacking off this, the reason they are holding off on announcing DS currently is that they are going to make it a BIG DEAL kind of announcement. It's introducing the 15th official class into the game. They are bringing back the last major Classic setting. And I think they a.) want this to be a huge event on it's own and b.) didn't want it overshadowing Ravenloft and Arcana Unleashed. They are going to make a huge marketing push out of this in the end of the year.
Care to explain this thought process? I see no reason a “Champions of Athas” book wouldn’t fit the season concept.Sure they will make a big deal announcement of DS. Which is yet another reason it’s not a season of champions.
Dark Sun isn’t about champions and heroes, the whole point is it is not heroic fantasy.Care to explain this thought process? I see no reason a “Champions of Athas” book wouldn’t fit the season concept.
The seasons are pseudonyms, they are overarching banners for a quarter. That includes the main book, and all the other products that release in that space.Dark Sun isn’t about champions and heroes, the whole point is it is not heroic fantasy.
Besides that, they are not going to prefigure a big deal announcement with a lame-ass pseudonym when they have already leaked that it’s on its way. They will announce it when they are ready to make a big deal of it.
I doubt it is DL, but not for your reasonsLast off topic post I’ll make, but there’s little to no chance the Champions book is Dragonlance or a Martial Champions book.
they held it back so the buzz is closer to the release date rather than now and by the time it actually arrives no one is talking about itThey held the announcement back for a later reveal. Likely at something like GaryCon or maybe even GenCon. That means they think it’s a big announcement that would generate buzz
pretty arbitrary timeline, I grant you FR and Eberron for those years.Their big 5 settings have, for the past two decades, been Faerun, Ravenloft, Eberron, Planescape, and Dark Sun. Only one of those hasn’t seen a release in the 5e era.

(Dungeons & Dragons)
Rulebook featuring "high magic" options, including a host of new spells.