a) The music was laughably bad.
"FATAL is the best roleplaying game I have ever seen!" = lulz
b) Some of the images were pretty cool, and I'd yoink them for any Far Realm/CoC game I wound up in.
So, how'd you find the images?
It appears that it is an RPG that isn't friendly to Eric's Grandma.
Yeah... FATAL isn't worth discussing this much. The people who haven't heard of it have been warned. Best to let sleeping dogs lie.
"2) Mix in every conceivable negative stereotype about underachievers in our society that you can find."
I don't disagree with your appraisal of the authors lack of merit in general, but they did manage to write two editions of the abominable thing. So perhaps they weren't underachievers. They were even perhaps overachievers at being vile.
Nomad4life, I have to commend you.
It is rare that creative works derived from/inspired by the intellectual property of others exceeds the quality of the original, but your compilation of images- culled from sources like WotC and FFG among others- set to FATAL's promo music actually surpasses both the music and FATAL itself.
OK, not like that was difficult to do, but hey, its a win!