SBMC said:Using a two handed weapon is best with Power Attack however in my experience the balance of AC vs. melee works best in the long run.
Power attack can also be used with great effect with a one handed weapon as well.
Yup, power attack works fine with a one-handed weapon. It's completely broken with a two-hander. And, as I noted in my original post, what I was proposing was a feat chain specifically designed for maximum damage-dealing.
All I can say is, come visit my Friday game. The fighter with the greatsword and the feat chain above just absolutely rips holes in things. He's got reasonably good AC as well (that's what he puts a lot of his treasure towards; I think he's got +3 full plate and a +2 ring of protection), but he rarely gets down into a dangerous zone on HP because:
(a) the party's healer tends to stand behind him, putting him back together as needed (because he *is* the party's beat-stick), and
(b) few creatures of anything approaching a level-appropriate CR can stand up to him for more than a round or two.