D&D 5E Rohirric Sword -- Short or Long?

[StriderUrbs]

So, I wanted to make a character based on the Rohirrim from Lord of the Rings, particularly Théoden. However, I know it may not be terribly important, but I was wondering whether the Rohirric swords in the films should be considered shortswords or longswords. It's about halfway, but I wanted to know what others thought about how it should be used in game.

 

[Ketser]

They are more longswords IMHO.

 

[was]

classic swords for horsemen are usually shorter than the standard longsword (and curved)

 

[Ketser]

classic swords for horsemen are usually shorter than the standard longsword (and curved)

Rohirrim used straight bladed swords, that were closer to a type of sword known as arming sword or knightly sword. So the longsword isn't the best pick, but probably closest to the ones used in books and movies. If you want a weapon closer to it, homebrew a version of longsword that lacks the versatile quality (maybe add finesse to balance out the loss of a trait).

 

[doctorbadwolf]

It's a short sword. Or a rapier. Or rather those are the swords closest to the right stats.

 

[mach1.9pants]

In 5E most weapons are not even described beyond their name (even in 3E lengths weren't mentioned) , so go wild! I would use longsword stats for no other reason that Theoden uses it in a slashing manner in battle, not piercing. Length wise, IMO, it could be argued either way. But really, what ever feels right to you.

 

[Flamestrike]

They're arming swords which in DnD have traditionally been 'long swords'.

But just let your player fluff it however he wants. Who cares?

If he wants to call his Longsword a Katana, Falcatta, Jian, Nine ring broadsword, Rohorric slashing death cutter or whatever it doesnt matter.

 

[doctorbadwolf]

How about:

Rohirrim Sword: one-handed, 1d8, Slashing and Piercing, Martial Melee Weapon


or, take a rapier and make it do slashing.

Changing damage types isnt isn't a big deal.

 

[Horwath]

To be devils advocate, it's and arming sword, or in DND terms a longsword.

one handed weapon, that can be used twohanded.

Even Theoden used it with two hands when he wanted to execute Grima, but Aragorn stopped him.

 

[Horwath]

As for lenght of "swords" here is rough classification,

Dagger 40-50cm,

Short sword 60-80cm,

Long sword 90-110cm,

greatsword 130-150cm,