RPGs being linked to murder...

Klaus

First Post
Here are some news that ran on Brazilian TV (translated for your ease):

In Minas Gerais (note: a state to the northwest of Rio), the mother of a female student murdered in a macabre ritual, in Ouro Preto (note: a small historical town in Minas Gerais) waits, for the past three years, for the solution of the misterious crime. Several suspects have been identified nut, to this day, no one was punished.
In the cemetary where her daughter was murdered, Maria José made a protest. "As long as there's impunity we will be putting the lives of other innocents in jeopardy".
Aline Soares was 18 years old and was participating in a student party. She was found killed, with 15 knife stabs and a deep cut along her throat, in the cementary of the Church of Mercies. Her body was laid in a cross-like position. On the body were found macabre drawings made with Aline's blood.
In the students' hostel where she was staying, the police found books on vampirism and RPG, a game where the participants assume the role of characters in a story. Five youngsters that were members of a "Sons of Satan" sect were arrested. All were liberated by an habeas corpus (note: a legal procedure where the accused can wait for the trial in liberty).
Three years after Aline's death, the process still hasn't been sent to court. According to the Ouro Preto D.A.'s office, the investigations performed by the town's civilian police (note: the branch of police that handles investigations, as opposed to the uniformed military police) are insuficient.
Today the case was once again sent back to the police station. D.A. Edvaldo Pereira Júnior wants a more thorough investigation. "The Public Ministery (note: the branch of government that defends the public and investigates) believes that the colection of more secure evidence is necessary for the jurors that will handle this case, more assured elements so they can judge in the most serene way possible".
The Public Ministery of Ouro Preto also asked the police superintendence for the appointment of a new investigation team. The family wants more D.A.s on the case, in hopes of ellucidating the case. "So that other mothers can grant liberty to their children and see them return home happy".

Jornal da Globo, October 14th, 2004

Yesterday the girl's cousin, Camilla, was arrested. The police no longer doubts she was an accessory to murder. Other four youngsters, three males and a female, are still at large. The deputy-chief said: "The girl (Camilla) lost in the game and had to offer something to the other participants, so she offered them Aline, who in turn had to give her life".

I'm beginning to worry that people are wrongly linking RPGs to murder, maybe due to the themes of certain games. And just FYI, the biggest-selling RPG in Brazil from the early 90's all the wat to 2001 was Vampire: The Masquerade (only the release of DnD 3.0 changed that). I just hope these people don't find out about "Dark Dungeons", as the prospect of RPGs being banned in Brazil isn't too impossible (they are already age-controlled; DnD, for instance, is prohibited from sale to people below 14; V:tM is prohibited to those below 16 or 18).
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Not too surprising that RPG's are getting the blame as its easier than addressing real social issues (stopping here to avoid political posting).

I didn't know that sale of RPG in Brazil was age controlled, I'm sure that some religious groups in the US and UK would love to be able to make that happen.
 

I'm sure that most of everything has been connected to murders at one point or another. Problems only arise when the subject is widely misunderstood, like RPGs. Nothing to worry about, IMO.

Never kept me from being open about playing RPGs. I've even mentioned it as a hobby in a job interview (otherwise the hobbies list would've been almost too short). I got the job, and it's come up a couple of times in coffee break talks - people generally don't know what it is, but do not think anything bad about it either. I'm happy to explain it, or just crack a joke or two about it if people aren't genuinely interested. Thats all there is to it - disregard BS issues like the news above, and explain the truth if situation warrants.

I'm always more interested about other aspects of crimes like this. Probably the satan worshipping was a more important aspect in the situation than the Vampire RPG. Even the fact that girl had 'lost' in an RPG underlines misunderstanding in the case. Or the more famous suicide case where D&D was blamed - ignoring the fact that the parents didn't know what their child was doing, had a loaded gun at home and still after the case didn't bother to find out what D&D was about. But I digress ..
 


Just when I thought I had escaped all "D&D is for satanists and murders" business, I meet a girl in a college class of mine last week that looks down and sees I am writing with a pencil that says "Dungeons and Dragons 30th Anniversary". With a frightened look on her face, she stares at me and says, "My dad would never let me play that game, he said it was for people that worship satan."

Agast, I stammer a bit - attempting to explain to someone that there may, indeed, be satanists that play Dungeons and Dragons - but the same is true for Monopoly, Scrabble, and any other game you can play... some people are satanists.

In the end, she becomes very interested and starts sending me notes about how to start playing... what books does she need, who can she play with, etc...
 

Queen_Dopplepopolis said:
Just when I thought I had escaped all "D&D is for satanists and murders" business, I meet a girl in a college class of mine last week that looks down and sees I am writing with a pencil that says "Dungeons and Dragons 30th Anniversary". With a frightened look on her face, she stares at me and says, "My dad would never let me play that game, he said it was for people that worship satan."

Agast, I stammer a bit - attempting to explain to someone that there may, indeed, be satanists that play Dungeons and Dragons - but the same is true for Monopoly, Scrabble, and any other game you can play... some people are satanists.

In the end, she becomes very interested and starts sending me notes about how to start playing... what books does she need, who can she play with, etc...
Yep. Satanism: The best press an RPG can get. :heh:

EDIT: just to be clear, I'm not making light of the victim in Brasil. there was a loss of life here, and though linking RPGs to satanism and murder is pretty laughable, we shouldn't lose sight that there was a tradedy involved.
 
Last edited:

I completely blame RPGs for my current situation - they had a major role in my downfall:

  • Wall St. Trader
  • Married 8 years to a beautiful, wonderful wife.
  • Father to wonderful 18 mos. old daughter.
  • Owner of ludicrously-priced NYC real-estate.
DAMN YOU, RPGs! DAMN YOU TO HELL!
 


Claudio,

CAR-PGa (Committee for the Advancement of Role-Playing Games) - the largest international gaming advocacy group - has been covering the Brazilian anti-RPG scene from day one.

If you like, I can put you in touch with our HQ in Texas or even with a CAR-PGa member in Brazil. They can help you defend RPGs in Brazil with advice and supporting material. CAR-PGa has the world's largest archive of media reports about RPGs.

CAR-PGa also maintains a Yahoo newsgroup. I don't know the URL off-hand but I can look it up if you like.

Alexander
CAR-PGa UK National Coordinator
 


Remove ads

Top