So which is better?

[garyh]

I voted Fellowship, but for a few resons that are no fault of TTT.

1 - I saw Fellowship 6 times in theaters, TTT only 3 times so far - though I plan on at least a couple more viewings.
2 - I have countless DVD viewings of Fellowship, so I'm more familiar and attached to it.
3 - I've had the benefit of the Extended Fellowship, which greatly enhances the movie, IMHO.

So, as I see TTT more, and watch the eventual TTT Extended edition, my opinion may change. We'll see.

 

[Agamon]

The first time I saw FotR, I stared wide-eyed, mouth agape in wonder. No one was sure if it'd be great, let alone good or even sucky. I wasn't sure what to expect, but as with all fantasy movies I've watched, I went in expecting little and hoping it'd be okay...

The first time I saw TTT I was in uncomfortable, in pain, and in a foul mood. Being the second part of what I consdier one of best movies I had ever seen, I went in with far higher expectations.

So, guess whcih movie I picked?

I'm thinking RotK will rule them all...