Survivor Magic Swords- FROST BRAND CHILLS THE COMPETITION!

[Adamant]

Dancing Sword 15
Defender 16
Dragon Slayer 21
Flame Tongue 19+1=20
Frost Brand 23
Holy Avenger 16
Luck Blade 23
Nine Lives Stealer 14
Sun Blade 23
Sword of Answering 13
Sword of Sharpness 21
Sword of Life Stealing 20
Sword + Something 8
Sword of Vengeance 16-2=14
Sword of Wounding 21
Vorpal Sword 17

 

[chrisrtld]

Dancing Sword 15
Defender 16
Dragon Slayer 21
Flame Tongue 20
Frost Brand 23
Holy Avenger 16
Luck Blade 24
Nine Lives Stealer 14
Sun Blade 23
Sword of Answering 13
Sword of Sharpness 21
Sword of Life Stealing 20
Sword + Something 6
Sword of Vengeance 14
Sword of Wounding 21
Vorpal Sword 17

 

[Ed Laprade]

Dancing Sword 15
Defender 16
Dragon Slayer 21
Flame Tongue 20 +1 = 21
Frost Brand 23
Holy Avenger 16
Luck Blade 24
Nine Lives Stealer 14
Sun Blade 23
Sword of Answering 13
Sword of Sharpness 21
Sword of Life Stealing 20
Sword + Something 6
Sword of Vengeance 14
Sword of Wounding 21
Vorpal Sword 17 -2 = 15

 

[Tallifer]

Dancing Sword 15
Defender 16
Dragon Slayer 21
Flame Tongue 21
Frost Brand 23
Holy Avenger 16
Luck Blade 22
Nine Lives Stealer 14
Sun Blade 23
Sword of Answering 13
Sword of Sharpness 21
Sword of Life Stealing 20
Sword + Something 6
Sword of Vengeance 14
Sword of Wounding 21
Vorpal Sword 16

How else are you going to slay the Jabberwock?

 

[Harzel]

Those are great ideas! I try to farm out the list to neutral conditions; this one is "DMG, Magic Swords." So they don't qualify.

Ah, I see what happened. They are in the DMG, but not in the (vanilla) 'Magic Items' section. Blackrazor and Moonblade are in the 'Sentient Magic Items' section and Sword of Kas is in the 'Artifacts' section.

No big deal whether they are included, of course, except for the question of whether you want two sentient weapons and an artifact thirsting for your blood.​

 

[StormbringerAUS]

Dancing Sword 15
Defender 16
Dragon Slayer 21
Flame Tongue 21 + 1 =22
Frost Brand 23 - 2 = 21
Holy Avenger 16
Luck Blade 22
Nine Lives Stealer 14
Sun Blade 23
Sword of Answering 13
Sword of Sharpness 21
Sword of Life Stealing 20
Sword + Something 6
Sword of Vengeance 14
Sword of Wounding 21
Vorpal Sword 16

 

[Harzel]

Dancing Sword 15
Defender 17
Dragon Slayer 21
Flame Tongue 22
Frost Brand 21
Holy Avenger 16
Luck Blade 22
Nine Lives Stealer 14
Sun Blade 23
Sword of Answering 13
Sword of Sharpness 21
Sword of Life Stealing 20
Sword + Something 4 - let's get this over with
Sword of Vengeance 14
Sword of Wounding 21
Vorpal Sword 16

 

[Eltab]

Dancing Sword 15
Defender 17
Dragon Slayer 21
Flame Tongue 22
Frost Brand 21
Holy Avenger 16
Luck Blade 22
Nine Lives Stealer 14
Sun Blade 23 - 2 = 21 Lightsabers belong in That Other Genre. 1M-watt floodlights belong in Yet Another Genre.
Sword of Answering 13
Sword of Sharpness 21
Sword of Life Stealing 20
Sword + Something 4 + 1 = 5 This is Excalibur in the movie of the same name. During the course of the movie, Arthur finds out (some of) what Something really means.
Sword of Vengeance 14
Sword of Wounding 21
Vorpal Sword 16

 

[Eltab]

How else are you going to slay the Jabberwock?

With something brillig.
Personally, I would go armed for hunting bandersnatchi. Frumious bandersnatchi.

 

[Tallifer]

Dancing Sword 15
Defender 17
Dragon Slayer 21
Flame Tongue 22
Frost Brand 21
Holy Avenger 16
Luck Blade 20
Nine Lives Stealer 14
Sun Blade 21
Sword of Answering 13
Sword of Sharpness 21
Sword of Life Stealing 20
Sword + Something 5
Sword of Vengeance 14
Sword of Wounding 21
Vorpal Sword 17