D&D 5E Survivor Swords: FLAME TONGUE WINS!

[Mr. Wilson]

+1 Basic Sword 19
Defender 17
Dragon Slayer 18
Flame Tongue 21
Frost Brand 22
Life Stealing 18
Luck Blade 19
Nine Lives Stealer 23
Sharpness 18
Vorpal 24
Wounding 16

Everyone who voted against the Holy Avengers obviously need a good smiting.

 

[Duan'duliir]

+1 Basic Sword 19
Defender 17
Dragon Slayer 18
Flame Tongue 21
Frost Brand 22
Life Stealing 18
Luck Blade 19
Nine Lives Stealer 21 - DOWN
Sharpness 18
Vorpal 25 - UP
Wounding 16

- Zynx, from the EN World mobile app

 

[Ed Laprade]

+1 Basic Sword 19 +1 = 20.
Defender 17
Dragon Slayer 18
Flame Tongue 21
Frost Brand 22
Life Stealing 18
Luck Blade 19
Nine Lives Stealer 21 -2 = 19.
Sharpness 18
Vorpal 25
Wounding 16

 

[Harzel]

+1 Basic Sword 18
Defender 17
Dragon Slayer 19
Flame Tongue 21
Frost Brand 22
Life Stealing 18
Luck Blade 19
Nine Lives Stealer 19
Sharpness 18
Vorpal 25
Wounding 16

 

[Tony Vargas]

+1 Basic Sword 18
Defender 18
Dragon Slayer 19
Flame Tongue 21
Frost Brand 22
Life Stealing 18
Luck Blade 19
Nine Lives Stealer 17
Sharpness 18
Vorpal 25
Wounding 16

 

[JonnyP71]

+1 Basic Sword 18
Defender 18
Dragon Slayer 19
Flame Tongue 21
Frost Brand 22
Life Stealing 17
Luck Blade 19
Nine Lives Stealer 18
Sharpness 18
Vorpal 25
Wounding 16

 

[ElderElementalEye]

+1 Basic Sword 18
Defender 18
Dragon Slayer 19
Flame Tongue 22
Frost Brand 22
Life Stealing 17
Luck Blade 19
Nine Lives Stealer 18
Sharpness 18
Vorpal 25
Wounding 14

 

[akr71]

+1 Basic Sword 18
Defender 18
Dragon Slayer 19
Flame Tongue 22
Frost Brand 22
Life Stealing 15
Luck Blade 19
Nine Lives Stealer 18
Sharpness 18
Vorpal 26
Wounding 14

 

[lowkey13]

*Deleted by user*

 

[Maxperson]

+1 Basic Sword 18
Defender 18
Dragon Slayer 19
Flame Tongue 22
Frost Brand 23
Life Stealing 15
Luck Blade 18
Nine Lives Stealer 18
Sharpness 18
Vorpal 24
Wounding 14

Yesterday I was walking to my car and I thought of the Pluck Blade. It's +1, +4 vs. feathered creatures. That idea alone is worth today's up vote.