D&D 5E Survivor Swords: FLAME TONGUE WINS!

[TwoSix]

Oh come on now. A paladin would use a basic magical sword and leave the defensive item to the more vulnerable party members. What's wrong with you?!?

You're right, a classic paladin says "I only get 10 items, so they better be good. +1 swords are for tithing!"
+1 Basic Sword 11
Defender 12
Flame Tongue 20
Frost Brand 20
Luck Blade 6
Sharpness 17
Vorpal 22

 

[UselessTriviaMan]

+1 Basic Sword 11
Defender 10
Flame Tongue 20
Frost Brand 20
Luck Blade 6
Sharpness 17
Vorpal 23

 

[Tony Vargas]

+1 Basic Sword 11
Defender 10
Flame Tongue 20
Frost Brand 20
Luck Blade 6
Sharpness 18
Vorpal 21

 

[Ed Laprade]

+1 Basic Sword 11 +1 = 12.
Defender 10
Flame Tongue 20
Frost Brand 20
Luck Blade 6 -2 = 4.
Sharpness 18
Vorpal 21

 

[Harzel]

+1 Basic Sword 12
Defender 11
Flame Tongue 20
Frost Brand 20
Luck Blade 4
Sharpness 18
Vorpal 19

 

[Duan'duliir]

+1 Basic Sword 12
Defender 11
Flame Tongue 18 - DOWN
Frost Brand 20
Luck Blade 4
Sharpness 18
Vorpal 20 - UP

- Zynx, from the EN World mobile app

 

[Ancalagon]

Ok, let's try not to screw the math this time (sorry about last post!)

+1 Basic Sword 13
Defender 9
Flame Tongue 18
Frost Brand 20
Luck Blade 4
Sharpness 18
Vorpal 20

 

[rgoodbb]

+1 Basic Sword 13
Defender 9
Flame Tongue 18
Frost Brand 20
Luck Blade 4
Sharpness 16
Vorpal 21

 

[JonnyP71]

+1 Basic Sword 13
Defender 7
Flame Tongue 18
Frost Brand 20
Luck Blade 4
Sharpness 17
Vorpal 21

 

[ElderElementalEye]

+1 Basic Sword 13
Defender 7
Flame Tongue 19
Frost Brand 20
Luck Blade 2
Sharpness 17
Vorpal 21