D&D 5E Survivor XGTE New Subclasses - SHADOW MAGIC WINS!

[Swarmkeeper]

9 Voted in favor of Hexblade, 5 votes against it, so nearly 2-to-1 in favor, and yet it's at 15 and ranked below average because of this silly "Downvotes = 3" system to "speed things up". That seems....not representative of the responses.

It's actually 7 to 5 for votes from unique users... there's an upvote on top of page 4 that didn't have green and two new unique down votes

 

[Phazonfish]

DOWNVOTES ARE THREE. PLEASE COPY AND PASTE THIS.

Ancestral Guardians 20
Storm Herald 17
Zealot 13
College of Swords 11
College of Glamour 15
College of Whispers 22
Forge Domain 22
Grave Domain 23
Circle of Shepherds 21
Cavalier 21
Samurai 21
Kensei 19
Drunken Master 13
Sun Soul 8
Oath of Conquest 7
Gloom Stalker 20
Horizon Walker 21
Monster Slayer 22 - I liked the UA version better, but hey it's not terrible as is
Scout 23
Inquisitive 15
Swashbuckler 22
Mastermind 18
Divine Soul 24
Shadow Magic 22
Storm Sorcerer 20
Hexblade 9
Celestial 24
War Magic 5 - Hey, here's an idea. Let's take our draft of a wizard subclass that is the most bookish wizard, and turn it into the least bookish wizard

 

[Twiggly the Gnome]

DOWNVOTES ARE THREE. PLEASE COPY AND PASTE THIS.

Ancestral Guardians 20
Storm Herald 17
Zealot 13
College of Swords 11
College of Glamour 15
College of Whispers 22
Forge Domain 22
Grave Domain 23
Circle of Shepherds 21
Cavalier 21
Samurai 21
Kensei 19
Drunken Master 13
Sun Soul 8
Oath of Conquest 4
Gloom Stalker 20
Horizon Walker 21
Monster Slayer 22
Scout 23
Inquisitive 15
Swashbuckler 22
Mastermind 18
Divine Soul 24
Shadow Magic 22
Storm Sorcerer 20
Hexblade 9
Celestial 25
War Magic 5

 

[Mistwell]

It's actually 7 to 5 for votes from unique users... there's an upvote on top of page 4 that didn't have green and two new unique down votes

I quoted them all. You can plainly see all 9. I am not counting points, you can see 9 people who upvoted it. Some people are choosing dark green instead of light green, which looks very close to black. My count was accurate. It's 9 upvotes, 5 downvotes, right now.

Also, page numbers are not consistent for people. Your page 4 is not my page 4, as I have my settings set to a different number of posts per page. Also, if people have you on ignore it can display additional messages instead of their messages which can also change page count.

 

[WayOfTheFourElements]

DOWNVOTES ARE THREE. PLEASE COPY AND PASTE THIS.

Ancestral Guardians 20
Storm Herald 17
Zealot 13
College of Swords 11
College of Glamour 12 - a hoggish swamp of disassociated mechanics I don't know how to described in game.
College of Whispers 23 - The first subclass I read in the book that I actually liked.
Forge Domain 22
Grave Domain 23
Circle of Shepherds 21
Cavalier 21
Samurai 21
Kensei 19
Drunken Master 13
Sun Soul 8
Oath of Conquest 4
Gloom Stalker 20
Horizon Walker 21
Monster Slayer 22
Scout 23
Inquisitive 15
Swashbuckler 22
Mastermind 18
Divine Soul 24
Shadow Magic 22
Storm Sorcerer 20
Hexblade 9
Celestial 25
War Magic 5

 

[bid]

DOWNVOTES ARE THREE. PLEASE COPY AND PASTE THIS.

Ancestral Guardians 20
Storm Herald 17
Zealot 13
College of Swords 11
College of Glamour 12
College of Whispers 23
Forge Domain 22
Grave Domain 23
Circle of Shepherds 21
Cavalier 21
Samurai 21
Kensei 20
Drunken Master 13
Sun Soul 8
Oath of Conquest 1
Gloom Stalker 20
Horizon Walker 21
Monster Slayer 22
Scout 23
Inquisitive 15
Swashbuckler 22
Mastermind 18
Divine Soul 24
Shadow Magic 22
Storm Sorcerer 20
Hexblade 9
Celestial 25
War Magic 5

Conquer this!

 

[MiraMels]

DOWNVOTES ARE THREE. PLEASE COPY AND PASTE THIS.

Ancestral Guardians 20
Storm Herald 17
Zealot 13
College of Swords 11
College of Glamour 12
College of Whispers 23
Forge Domain 22
Grave Domain 23
Circle of Shepherds 21
Cavalier 21
Samurai 21
Kensei 20
Drunken Master 13
Sun Soul 8
Oath of Conquest -2 Shameful that they would even call this a paladin. Those of this oath are unworthy of the name. It's my pleasure to see them off this list. Praise the sun.
Gloom Stalker 20
Horizon Walker 21
Monster Slayer 22
Scout 23
Inquisitive 15
Swashbuckler 22
Mastermind 18
Divine Soul 25
Shadow Magic 22
Storm Sorcerer 20
Hexblade 9
Celestial 25
War Magic 5

 

[Ogre Mage]

DOWNVOTES ARE THREE. PLEASE COPY AND PASTE THIS.

Ancestral Guardians 20
Storm Herald 17
Zealot 13
College of Swords 11
College of Glamour 12
College of Whispers 23
Forge Domain 22
Grave Domain 23
Circle of Shepherds 21
Cavalier 21
Samurai 21
Kensei 20
Drunken Master 13
Sun Soul 5 -- this one is also stuck where the sun don't shine
Gloom Stalker 20
Horizon Walker 21
Monster Slayer 22
Scout 23
Inquisitive 15
Swashbuckler 22
Mastermind 18
Divine Soul 25
Shadow Magic 22
Storm Sorcerer 20
Hexblade 10 -- I could see myself playing this
Celestial 25
War Magic 5

 

[gyor]

DOWNVOTES ARE THREE. PLEASE COPY AND PASTE THIS.

Ancestral Guardians 20
Storm Herald 17
Zealot 13
College of Swords 11
College of Glamour 12
College of Whispers 23
Forge Domain 22
Grave Domain 23
Circle of Shepherds 21
Cavalier 21
Samurai 21
Kensei 20
Drunken Master 13
Sun Soul 5 
Gloom Stalker 20
Horizon Walker 21
Monster Slayer 22
Scout 23
Inquisitive 15
Swashbuckler 22
Mastermind 15 -3 this should have come with minions.
Divine Soul 26 +1 a fun subclass
Shadow Magic 22
Storm Sorcerer 20
Hexblade 10 
Celestial 25
War Magic 5

 

[Phion]

DOWNVOTES ARE THREE. PLEASE COPY AND PASTE THIS.

Ancestral Guardians 20
Storm Herald 17
Zealot 13
College of Swords 11
College of Glamour 12
College of Whispers 23
Forge Domain 22
Grave Domain 23
Circle of Shepherds 21
Cavalier 21
Samurai 21
Kensei 20
Drunken Master 13
Sun Soul 5
Gloom Stalker 20
Horizon Walker 22- I like this guy, it has a Matrix/inception feel to it. Not sure how I would role-play this in a interesting manner but someone should have a idea
Monster Slayer 19- To be honest this is just a bitter point deduction, I wanted the fighter to have this kind of archetype like Monster hunter (only improved from unearthed arcana)
Scout 23
Inquisitive 15
Swashbuckler 22
Mastermind 12
Divine Soul 27
Shadow Magic 22
Storm Sorcerer 20
Hexblade 10
Celestial 25
War Magic 5