The first was
Between Books. They have been around since the late 70s. It is primarily a bookstore (with a very large fantasy/science fiction section...almost half of the stock). It also is a comic book store, game store and a bit of a "new age" store.
The gaming area is somewhat small. I used to run WizKids games in the back and we were at capacity a few nights with as many as 14 players (which consisted of 2 battles of 2 players sitting on the floor in the corners). The gaming is haphazard because the gaming area is in the store, and we are somewhat restricted to store hours.
Greg, the owner (well, one of several) is one of the nicest guys you will ever meet. If a comic book soars in value, he will refuse to sell it for higher than cover price. The RPG and game stock has many old hard to find gems buried. While you won't see a sale very often, you will never see the price above cover price, either.