Eeeewwwww!! Devil girls have really bad breath (and cankles)! Her kiss left me feeling weak...and not in a good way!!
BTW, Celtavian, that drawing Doc did for Wee Jas is not Drexel, it's another character named Ikhat. (I think Wee Jas thought you were asking if he played Drexel...) Ikhat is in another campaign that Xaltar DMs on Wednesdays.
My party never falls for the "innocent looking person in the villian's dungeon" trick. Of course I've worked hard to make them very, very paranoid. They carry weapons in their bath
I pulled the same trick on our female thief. It was the succubus in the Fordge of Fury. She lost a level. It gave her a big old smack on the lips. Needless to say, poor damsels found in distress STAY in distress.
What about the whole women screaming off the side of the road with monsters around her thing? That would make a good place to put a sucubus. Have her run into the paladin's arms and such.
My players tend to be so paranoid that pretty much everything gets set on fire. And if not, then anyone "rescued" ends up in chains until they finish clearing out a dungeon.