My obsession is also relatively recent, but I never play a game anymore that I don't think "I wonder how easy it would be to add aspects to this game? I wonder if I could get the other guys to buy into it?" When that is your reaction to a game, I think you gotta go with the game that has aspects from the beginning.
The Poll
- Thread starter thecasualoblivion
- Start date
My obsession is also relatively recent, but I never play a game anymore that I don't think "I wonder how easy it would be to add aspects to this game? I wonder if I could get the other guys to buy into it?" When that is your reaction to a game, I think you gotta go with the game that has aspects from the beginning.
El Mahdi
Muad'Dib of the Anauroch
A Winner of the Poll....but it won['t let me give you XP sorry, it says I have already given you some and I need to spread the love
That's alright. Spread the love around man.
I only answered because I like aircraft (I guess I'd have to after 21 years of aircraft maintenance). I was stationed in the UK for 6 years, and also saw my fair share of Tornado's during Operation Provide Comfort in Turkey (Incirlik). So, there's not much chance I wouldn't recognize one. I'd get a wake-up every morning when the Tornado's and F-111's took off.
The Shaman
First Post
non-D&D/non-d20
Fantasy just ain't my bag.
Fantasy just ain't my bag.
Remathilis
Legend
I, of course, voted to burn them all; as they are tools of Satan.
But if I had to burn one last; I think it would be 3e.
But if I had to burn one last; I think it would be 3e.
Invisible Stalker
First Post
1. 1e
2. BCEMI
3. 4e
4. I guess non D&D would be here
5. 3e
6. 2e
2. BCEMI
3. 4e
4. I guess non D&D would be here
5. 3e
6. 2e
thecasualoblivion
First Post
After about a day of this, a point:
I put this poll up on both ENWorld and RPGnet, because I wanted to compare the results.
ENWorld
4E D&D/GSL 94 44.13%
3E D&D/OGL/d20(minus retro clones) 82 38.50%
OD&D/1E/2E/BEMCI/Retro Clones 24 11.27%
non-D&D/non-d20 13 6.10%
RPGnet
4E D&D/GSL 66 51.16%
3E D&D/OGL/d20(minus retro clones) 10 7.75%
OD&D/1E/2E/BEMCI/Retro Clones 28 21.71%
non-D&D/non-d20 25 19.38%
4E comes out ahead in both polls, with RPGnet having a greater percentage but not by too much. Old School and non-D&D got a lot more votes over at RPGnet. The biggest difference between the two forums is the difference between 3E/OGL, where ENWorld got 38.50% while RPGnet it got only 7.75%.
I put this poll up on both ENWorld and RPGnet, because I wanted to compare the results.
ENWorld
4E D&D/GSL 94 44.13%
3E D&D/OGL/d20(minus retro clones) 82 38.50%
OD&D/1E/2E/BEMCI/Retro Clones 24 11.27%
non-D&D/non-d20 13 6.10%
RPGnet
4E D&D/GSL 66 51.16%
3E D&D/OGL/d20(minus retro clones) 10 7.75%
OD&D/1E/2E/BEMCI/Retro Clones 28 21.71%
non-D&D/non-d20 25 19.38%
4E comes out ahead in both polls, with RPGnet having a greater percentage but not by too much. Old School and non-D&D got a lot more votes over at RPGnet. The biggest difference between the two forums is the difference between 3E/OGL, where ENWorld got 38.50% while RPGnet it got only 7.75%.
lutecius
Explorer
This would be a bit more reliable if it was a public poll.
thecasualoblivion
First Post
Depends on the purpose of the poll. If I was measuring sentiment of various game systems, a public poll would be more reliable. If on the other hand I was just comparing sentiment between ENWorld and RPGnet, this poll works just fine.
lutecius
Explorer
I think it would be more reliable in both cases.
Out of curiosity, do they have public polls (or logged-in only) over there?
Similar Threads
- Poll
