The Quintessential Fighter - What do you all think?

[Thorntangle]

Re: Re: The Quintessential Fighter - What do you all think?

pg 41 Two-Handed Power Strike:
This Feat is disallowed.

Why did you disallow this feat? Just curious. It's kind of like Dirty Fighting - it doesn't scale since it's a full round action. Once you get multiple attacks it doesn't make sense to use it.

 

[Crothian]

I looked over the Quintessential Fighter back when it came out, and ir put me off ever using Mongoose material in any game I run.

I think that's a little harsh. Quint Fighter did have some problems, but Mongoose has really increased the production values of their books since then. Did you pick up CC1 and then swear off Sword and Sorcery? Or swear of Wizards books when S&F came out? All companies have good and bad products. One just needs to be careful and make sure that one is only getting the good stuff.

 

[S'mon]

Re: Re: Re: The Quintessential Fighter - What do you all think?

Why did you disallow this feat? Just curious. It's kind of like Dirty Fighting - it doesn't scale since it's a full round action. Once you get multiple attacks it doesn't make sense to use it.

It's not a Full Round Action (as written), what it says is that you can only use it while taking a full attack action.

Your way is better though!

 

[Thorntangle]

Re: Re: Re: Re: The Quintessential Fighter - What do you all think?

It's not a Full Round Action (as written), what it says is that you can only use it while taking a full attack action.

Your way is better though!

Er, sorry. That's actually what I meant. You can only use it as a full attack action, just like Dirty Fighting. As I understand the FAQ, that means that you either get 1 attack if you use this feat, or multiple attacks (if you have them) without using the feat.

 

[S'mon]

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: The Quintessential Fighter - What do you all think?

Er, sorry. That's actually what I meant. You can only use it as a full attack action, just like Dirty Fighting. As I understand the FAQ, that means that you either get 1 attack if you use this feat, or multiple attacks (if you have them) without using the feat.

That's not how QF writes it, though. Not to worry.