Will My PC Figure This Out?
Will my campaign's lone PC (named Dior) figure this one out: too early, too late, just right (after a few murders)?
The murderer is the Method Actor, and he has some blackmail and morally questionable behavior. The motive is to advance his artistic agenda by getting his followers in the understudies to prominent roles. The means are "accidents."
0. The Method Actor begins hiding easily-found liquor bottles throughout the theater, hoping the Avuncular Drunk gets rid of himself by drinking himself out of a job.
Can be discovered by a search check.
1. Murder of the Aging Battle Axe : Midway through rehearsals, killed by falling sandbag to advance career of Bina (an extra into the Method Actor's groove) after Dior’s gone. Declared an accident by people at theater, but Sgt. Durph takes his time with the body and the scene. Then declares it an accident.
Murdered first because any number of understudies, Ingenue, Avuncular Drunk, Impressario, Ghost, and Dior could have wanted her dead. Also throws suspicion towards those who hate Dior too, as it could have been Dior, but she was sick that day of rehearsal, resting her voice.
Can be discovered as murder by checking the ropes themselves. Could guess motive from the Bore (a Method extra who's already ascended due to the quality of his voice), Bina, and conversation. Couldn’t prove anything, however, without slipping Method Actor an elixir of love and a kickin’ Diplomacy check, which would only get him to recruit Dior. Confession likely thrown out in court under these circumstances.
2. Blackmail of Gorsky the Impressario: Method Actor next finds out about the Mob-Gorsky connection, he’ll start blackmailing Gorsky to cast his people, threatening to tell his other investors of his true financial position or to inform to the Mob boss about how badly rehearsals are going. He’d offer himself as the solution to Finn, the Mob boss, never realizing the danger or admitting the possibility of being wrong about his acolytes.
If he’s feeling pressure from Dior’s suspicion, he’ll kill Gorsky hoping to push attention on Finn.
Can be uncovered through gathering info in underworld and figuring out precarious finances, Impressario's increasing desperation for show to go on, guessing that understudies had some help from watching them, speaking with dead on the Lech (later), or intimidating it out of Gorsky.
3. Murder of the Letch : Killed due to blackmailing, but also advances Edwin’s career, a stupid and handsome extra into the Method. He saw the Method Actor hiding liquor in the Avuncular Drunk’s room while he was returning from spying on the nocturnal activities of the Ingenue and Edwin. Figured out that the Method extras were getting promoted via blackmail and skullduggery, tried to blackmail the Method actor for some lovin’ from the extras. He was expecting a girl to visit him, as agreed, when he died. Has cost of throwing suspicion on to the Ingenue, whom the Method Actor believes is a convert to his agenda. Suspects include every woman who ever met him, and Gorsky.
Murdered on stage after the original dulled weapon is “misplaced” backstage and a real one is used by the Bore, who really does kill him on stage. It’s the performance of the Lech’s life. Killing in this way also aids the Bore, who may become a better actor due to the trauma of the experience.
Hidden passage indicates forbidden knowledge, Speak with Dead details attempted blackmail, lack of an extra who was going to meet him indicates premeditated murder. Find the missing weapon!
4. Murder of the Avuncular Drunk: Killed because he’s taking too long to drink himself out of the part, if Dior stops him. Falls down stairs, due to a shove. Killing advances career of Jardin, a pedantic actor not yet a convert to the Method, but likely will become one.
Since he’s been drinking more heavily in mourning for the Aging Battle Axe, it looks like an accident. It throws suspicion on the Impressario, and, perhaps, on the Ingenue (if people put together the relationship with Edwin, or an embarassing scene on stage). Who doesn’t want the unreliable lead replaced by his understudy?
Extra bottles indicate malice aforethought, physical evidence leads to murder, re-examining physical evidence eventually indicates prior accident was murder, footprint moves investigation away from Finn.
Murder of Child Impersonator: Strangled hastily for what he saw. Murderer has no alibi for the crime. Victim saw who murdered him.
Murder of Janis the Gossip: Falling axe from wall mount kills her for what she heard. No alibi.
Clues:
• Search for bottles: A Search 20 of the entire theater turns up way too many bottles for even the Avuncular Drunk to have hidden himself.
• Motive: That the replacements are all Method actors or likely to become so can be discovered by asking them the right questions or gathering information about this issue directly. Nobody volunteers the acting philosophy because they regard it as irrelevant unless directly asked.
• Why’s the Battle Axe on the Warpath? A diplomacy check on the Ingenue, Impressario, or Drunk discovers that she’s upset with Gorsky over casting Dior and having a love scene between the Ingenue and the Avuncular Drunk, who were lovers.
• The Avuncular Drunk Knows: He was trying to advise the Ingenue to drop the Method Actor, whom he suspected of unchivalrously using her. A Listen check catches the end of a blow-up argument between himself and the Method Actor.
• Cops/Physical Evidence: On 2nd murder scene, Search 25 sees a scuff mark from a shoe not of the Child Impersonator’s size and identifies it as significant because it is roughly of the same age of the scene by the amount of dust there. Cops will provide data if the PC is absolutely stuck.
• Cops/Physical Evidence: Due to 2nd murder, that leads Durph to test ropes similar to those from the first murder with fraying and with knife. Concludes after a day the rope was cut with a very sharp knife. Immediately fixates on following up the Scurvytown red herrings (the Mob, the Fight master), then on the Ingenue.
• Cops/Physical Evidence: Bianca Altanish, Life Researcher, discovers a pin-prick hole at the cartoid artery in the Avuncular Drunk’s neck while preparing his body for cremation. This is inconsistent with a fall and points to murder after the fall left the man helpless.
• Cops/Physical Evidence: Bianca Altanish notes at the scene of the crime that the strangulation marks come from a human man with below average strength, wielding a rope from behind.
• Cops/Physical Evidence: Bianca Altanish notes at the scene of the crime that this body is that of a halfling, not a human boy.
• Cops/Physical Evidence: Sargent Durph finds a broken piece of string near the axe that killed Janis, which was how the axe fell.
• Search: The Lech spies on women in their dressing room. Search to find hidden passage or holes in walls.
• The Ingenue’s Sex Life:
o Diplomacy among the main cast reveals rumors of her casting couch session with Gorsky to escape the extras, her rejection of the Lech, her October-May affair with the Avuncular Drunk and resulting blow-ups with the Battle Axe, and her current affair with the Method Actor.
o A Gather Info check among the stage-hands finds the above plus that she’s been seen canoodling with a handsome extra behind the Method Actor’s back.
o A Gather Info check among the musicians finds none of those rumors but instead that Gorsky believes she’ll never be a star.
o A Gather Info check among the extras finds the current affair and that she’s a believer in the Method. She isn’t, but they believe she is because she tells the men she’s sleeping with what they want to hear.
• Presence of a Curse: Red Herring, but also why the Method Actor acts now
o Tristan and Isolde has a reputation of being haunted by ill-fortune.
o A GI check 10 reveals ghost tales and speculation that it’s the composer, a neglected extra, or the spirit of an anguished Ingenue seduced and abandoned. Told in a manner of kidding around, theatrically, or to scare the Noobs and extras.
o A Search check 20 of the archives of the Lydian temple or a Diplomacy 15 of the gossip or the drunk leads to the knowledge of a ghost. Every 5 by which this succeeds, reveals an extra clue: never someone with good reviews, death by a panicked flight through the theater, death by accident (a falling axe), or a visiting performer who died of stage fright before her first performance. There’s also more than a few reports on backstage drama in EVERY performance.
• Finances: The Swan Street Slicer is dragging down sales. (Gather Info 10 results in idle conversation with box office gossip.) Success here gives +2 circumstance bonus to uncovering financial difficulties.
• Finances: The theater and the Impressario are in financial difficulties. (This can be uncovered with a Gather Information 15 check in the right underworld circles, a GI 25 elsewhere, a Search check on the reviews and news coverage, or with a Sense Motive DC 26.) The money troubles motivate his unusual casting of the PC against vocal type and his PR use of her heroism.
• Finances: Janis is skimming lightly off the top, which prevents her from coming forward later. Can be uncovered by catching her in the act, after hours, or by a search through the financial records of the theater by a professional.
• The Child Impersonator is on the scene for every discovery of the murders.
o “That’s No Boy!”: Seeing through the disguise requires a Spot 22. Clues to real identity include Perform +0 skill (although he is a good actor) and he has to re-roll his Disguise +12 when around cards at a -2 modifier due to his addiciton to gambling. This is how the Method Actor knows his real identity.
o The Cabin Girl: Dior has the good luck to have a cabin girl, Rajya, who knows the real Timothy on sight, as he belonged to an Easterners rival group of kids until recently. “He used to pull her hair and throw rocks, but otherwise he was kinda nice. You know. [Nods]” If pressed, she gives a story that starts in the middle, rockets right to the beginning, then off-handedly mentions the end.
• Otto Parsam the Fight Master: Under diplomacy, will admit that he dislikes the Lech (lack of manliness), the Bore (lack of charisma in his fighting), and works in Scurvytown (Knowledge: Local).
• Who was last seen with the missing dulled weapon?
Divination Spells:
• Speak with Dead is easy. The victims don't know much about the murderer: the Aging Battle Axe was due to a trap, the push from behind for the Avuncular Drunk, the falling axe was a remote controlled trap for the Gossip, the strangulation from behind of the Lech… The spell does reveal the Lech’s blackmail scheme, the blackmailing (only) of Gorsky by the Method Actor, and that he was waiting for some lovin’.
• The method actor will probably be immune to Detect Thoughts most of the time. It only detects surface thoughts, and he can use his acting training to "get into character" in a way that moves any thoughts of guilt away from the forefront of his mind. His training means that he can use his Disguise/Performance check instead of his Will save.
• Zone of Truth might be foiled through half-truths or refusals to answer or appeals to their physical relationship.
• The theater itself detects as evil while the ghost remains. The Method Actor, the Lech, the Child Impersonator, and the Ingenue all read as low-powered, selfish evil.