A few bucks can be made. I dont think anyone expects it to be a hit.My question is simply: who is this for? I can't imagine too many Traveller fans want it in a completely different, class and level based system. And 5E already has a metric ton of sci-fi adaptations out there. Why does this exist?
Why not?I mean...sure. But why?
Oh good lord. Who is this for?My question is simply: who is this for? I can't imagine too many Traveller fans want it in a completely different, class and level based system. And 5E already has a metric ton of sci-fi adaptations out there. Why does this exist?
I love them both, but they juat don't fit. 5E sci-fi is totally doable, but it would necessarily be kind of a high-powered gonzo Sci-Fi...which is not Traveller. It is not a heroic story milieu, not in the same high octane action that 5E provides at least.My question is simply: who is this for? I can't imagine too many Traveller fans want it in a completely different, class and level based system. And 5E already has a metric ton of sci-fi adaptations out there. Why does this exist?
I'm a big fan of the heroic dungeoneering action of 5E, and I am not necessarily a purist about Traveller. I just fail to see what a high-octane action engine has to offer for a low-key, non-actuon oriented setting like the Third Imperium.Why not?
This new version likely won't appeal to Traveller purists . . . so?
It will likely appeal to folks who are Traveller curious, and don't often play games that aren't 5E adjacent.
Not every game is for everyone.
I thought so too but Carbon 2185 has shown me that the power level can be curbed and adapted. So, it’s not as far apart as it might seem. I’m guessing if this thing bombs hugely it will be because it misses both 5E and Traveller feel.I love them both, but they juat don't fit. 5E sci-fi is totally doable, but it would necessarily be kind of a high-powered gonzo Sci-Fi...which is not Traveller. It is not a heroic story milieu, not in the same high octane action that 5E provides at least.
That's a fair point, I think of 5e as high-powered because of the player characters' ability to punch well above their weight class... but while this uses 5e's engine, that doesn't mean it'll be "5e-compatible" where everything will be the same power level/backwards-compatible with 5e.I thought so too but Carbon 2185 has shown me that the power level can be curbed and adapted. So, it’s not as far apart as it might seem. I’m guessing if this thing bombs hugely it will be because it misses both 5E and Traveller feel.
That's true. The 5e adaptation of Middle-Earth (both versions) are hardly at the same power level as WotC 5e.That's a fair point, I think of 5e as high-powered because of the player characters' ability to punch well above their weight class... but while this uses 5e's engine, that doesn't mean it'll be "5e-compatible" where everything will be the same power level/backwards-compatible with 5e.