Trying to add a review

[Skade]

Hi there. I just attempted to add a review for the Emerald Sage, and was unable to do so. It seems that neither company involved is on the drop down menu of publishers.

 

[Blacksway]

You Tell Big Porkies! Its there twice (as is your review!)

 

[Krug]

however, it's an e-zine... should it be listed in reviews?

 

[HellHound]

After several requests to add Realms of Evil Games "Stygian" to the review database, it was stated that e-zines and even print magazines would NOT be added to the database.

 

[Horacio]

It is a free product made jointly by two d20 publishers. The "e-zine" denomination only means that we want to release several issues.

It is a free product, that will have "sons", a bit like Portable Hole Full of Beer and now its "issue 2", Portable Hole Full of Beer II. If the word e-zine is the problem, we will drop it. Because I hope the problem is not that it's free...

 

[Psion]

After several requests to add Realms of Evil Games "Stygian" to the review database, it was stated that e-zines and even print magazines would NOT be added to the database.

That's a good point. I would say allow both or neither.

I'll present this point before the proper authorities...

 

[Psion]

It is a free product, that will have "sons", a bit like Portable Hole Full of Beer and now its "issue 2", Portable Hole Full of Beer II.

True, but by the same token, the RoE folks could put out there e-zine as a number of like-named modules, like Stygian: Blight in the Wilderness or Stygian: Pig in the City. (or whatever)

 

[Skade]

You Tell Big Porkies! Its there twice (as is your review!)

Yeah, I posted this before I was informed that the issues had been approved for reviews. I should have deleted this when I did that. Sorry.

 

[Horacio]

True, but by the same token, the RoE folks could put out there e-zine as a number of like-named modules, like Stygian: Blight in the Wilderness or Stygian: Pig in the City. (or whatever)

Yup, they can do it. I don't see why not.

Again, what is the difference with Portable Hole and Son of Portable Hole?

(BTW, Hound, sorry to pick Portable Hole as example. Take it as a praise, it is a product so good that nobody would think of putting it outside the reviews list...)

 

[Psion]

Yup, they can do it. I don't see why not.

Again, what is the difference with Portable Hole and Son of Portable Hole?

Well, PHFOB has content more like a product vice periodical for one. It does not have much in the way of interviews, company news, or product reviews.