Tuesdays are Supernatural!

[WayneLigon]

I liked it. I especially liked that they had someone from their past call them in.

 

[Steverooo]

I liked it. I especially liked that they had someone from their past call them in.

That was the ONLY part of it that I DID like... This show is a real wiener!

Spoiler

I predict that this show will last one season, or less, barring majorly changing course!

 

[Crothian]

It was a good show. I like that it is patient. They get a few episodes were they set up themselves and now it is showing that they might be having peoiple calling them looking for help.

and that predicition is probably a safe bet based only that it is on WB, it seems a good number of their shows just don't make it no matter the quality

 

[Christoph the Magus]

Me neither, as long as there is regular progress. I've been rewatching the X-files on DVD from Netflix for the last few months, it's there's a noticable difference on how intriguing "mythos" episodes are vs. "freak of the week." I like the sense of the show going somewhere, and I was a bit surprised that at the end of the second episode, there were no obvious leads into the third.

I'm just the opposite. The best Xfiles IMO were the freak of the week shows. Things started to get really boring when it just became "237-We see weird stuff and the government is still trying to keep a lid on it".


The longer SN can stay "freek of the week" the better, IMO.

 

[Steverooo]

Well, the series was just picked up for the rest of the season, but I am doubting that there will be a second... There is very little buzz about it, here on the boards... So, is no one watching? I actually thought that this week's episode was a half-decent one, although still FotW...

 

[Ao the Overkitty]

I actually thought yesterday's ep wasn't as good as the past few. It just kinda felt formulaic.

 

[Desdichado]

I thought yesterday's episode was the best so far, if a little derivative of The Ring. Very creepy. And, it's starting to tie back to "the big picture."

Steveroo, do you have anything to add other than complaints and doom and gloom? If this show is so execrable to you, why are you still watching, and being the first to post any tiny little bit of news about it?

EDIT: to be clear; this isn't meant as an attack or a criticism; I'm just genuinely curious why he seems so interested in something that he professes to dislike so much.

 

[Kaledor]

I loved the Bloody Mary episode.

I liked the tie in to the bigger picture with Sam's guilt.
I thought it was better than last week's and about just as good as the first ep. Very creepy. Sure, we've seen the effects before... but to me, they were still very well done and still very chilling! Creepy girls in reflections always get me

I like that in this ep. they weren't completely sure how to finish off the creature. I wish they had played to that more (perhaps shown them researching ways of killing spirits or running through a list of ways...) I would have liked to see more tricks like we did in the first ep (salt, magic circles, ...).

And I'm still really enjoying the by-play between the two characters.
(I just wish they'd STOP showing them talking in the car while driving, the effects crew hasn't nailed that down yet and it always looks bad IMO).



btw. I predict that this will last more than a season -- no reason, I just wanted to voice the other side.

 

[Captain Tagon]

Another fun episode that while still FotW managed to tie in a lot of mythos as well. These days this is the only show on television I make time to watch, though it coming on in the middle of the week probably helps.

 

[fett527]

I watched an thought it was ok. It was enough that I'll watch the next episode. And the girl was creepy goodness.