Various HD feats

[Scion]

Uh, I think you pointed out why he believes its balanced (if you try to 'trick the system' by buying both options, the total effect is nil).

Not sure why you quoted me, I am the one who made the original post

[
Final note: this shouldn't be a feat, but an option in character creation: spending a feat and gaining 2 feats is the same as saying -x hp for +1 feat, remove the redundant feat on either side of the equation.

I understand what you mean, but i'd rather just put it on the feat list instead of making a whole new mechanic. The overall difference isnt so extreme as to be a big deal

It just seems cool for a character to get a bit farther along in feats than they otherwise could, but at a cost. Does anyone see any big blatant balance issues that I am missing? Havent had a problem with the revised toughness feat, those who take it still take it for the same reasons but dont feel like they wasted a feat later on. Personally I feel that it is still pretty weak even at +1hp/hd, but at least it has good flavor instead of just the +3 which is worthless after 3rd level for most characters.

 

[LightPhoenix]

Right, I'm obviously a doof.

I promise, I'll work on that reading thing before I post again...

 

[Beholder Bob]

Not sure why you quoted me, I am the one who made the original post ...QUOTE]

Would you believe temporary insanity?

 

[AeroDm]

Clearly this thread is evil. No one can reply without making themselves appear as an ass.

On topic- I guess there aren't really any balance issues overall. It is powerful, but perhaps not as powerful as some other feats in the game. If you feel it would work in your game, then I think it will prove enjoyable and worthwhile.

 

[Scion]

Clearly this thread is evil. No one can reply without making themselves appear as an ass.

Aww

On topic- I guess there aren't really any balance issues overall. It is powerful, but perhaps not as powerful as some other feats in the game. If you feel it would work in your game, then I think it will prove enjoyable and worthwhile.

Thanks for the note, it probably is a strong feat, and can have some odd things happen. Overall though I'll let some people play with it and see if it goes well, currently I'm not terribly worried as no one has jumped up and down on me screaming about brokeness with such and such combo

Have a good one all.